Catalogue of Recommendations on Electoral Reform

This Catalogue is a collection of recommendations issued by citizen observer organisations in Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Georgia, Moldova, Russia and Ukraine with regard to elections observed since 2012. It was developed by the EPDE with the aim of supporting these organizations’ efforts of tracking the implementation of recommendations and of encouraging follow-up and engagement on their basis to improve the conduct of elections.

Information contained in this Catalogue has been compiled on the basis of citizen observer organisations’ published election observation reports. Evaluations regarding the extent of implementation of individual recommendations have been provided by the respective organizations. For a comprehensive picture, recommendations and evaluations should be read in conjunction with the original full reports. Records in this Catalogue will be subject to regular update.

Filter

Reset all filter settings.

Catalogue of Recommendations

1100 entries were found.

Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Voting abroad
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Coordination among responsible institutions
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Out-of-Country Voting
Recommendation:
Introduce a new concept of distributing duties among the state institutions involved in the organisation and conduct of elections abroad. According to this concept, the CEC would be responsible for the process, with the assistance of the MFAEI.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Out-of-Country Voting
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Structure (clarity, comprehensiveness, codification, consistency)
Recommendation:
Amend Article 291 of the Electoral Code to establish three indicators as the legal basis for identifying the number and geographic distribution of polling stations abroad: the number of voters who participated in the previous election; statistical data in the State Registry of Population on the number of Moldovan citizens who have permanent residency abroad; and prior registration of citizens abroad.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Voting abroad
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Election commissions abroad
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Election day procedures
Recommendation:
Modify Article 27 of the Electoral Code to allow PSs abroad to perform their work under a separate constituency. There is a need to expressly establish an ECC in charge of conducting voting abroad.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Support signatures
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
Eliminate the requirement that local public authorities authenticate signature sheets in national elections. Promo-LEX EOM has demonstrated the inefficiency of signature sheet authentication in this report. This change would allow a more inclusive approach towards the citizens with the right to vote abroad and on the left bank of Nistru River who would like to sign the lists.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Out-of-Country Voting
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Election materials
Recommendation:
Amend the Electoral Code with regard to the maximum number of ballot papers allowed in PSs abroad. This presidential election showed that up to 6,000 ballot papers can be processed at a PS.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign silence
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Fraud and irregularities (including attemps of influencing voters)
Recommendation:
Consider the explicit legal regulation of the organised transportation of voters, including from the perspective of the risk of voter corruption.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Effective legal redress
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Recommendation:
Amend the Electoral Code to explicitly regulate appeal procedures and the resolution of complaints by electoral bodies and courts of law. In particular, the following should be considered in presidential elections: opportunities for submitting complaints during signature collection, the competence of the CEC to review these appeals, the opportunity to submit complaints during vote tabulation regarding voting results in a particular PS, etc.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Implementation in line with the spirit of the law
Recommendation:
Supplement the Electoral Code with an express provision obligating the CEC itself to take action in cases of violations of electoral legislation.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Bribing and distribution of inducements to voters
Recommendation:
Approve a revision of the Article 181(1) of the Criminal Code supplementing the list of goods that cannot be offered to the voters, and applying the provisions of this article to presidential elections.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Structure (clarity, comprehensiveness, codification, consistency)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Support signatures
Recommendation:
Explicitly regulate the categories of persons entitled to collect signatures in support of nominated candidates. Impose sanctions for the collection of signatures by unauthorised persons.
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Structure (clarity, comprehensiveness, codification, consistency)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
Amend the legal framework by introducing conditions of incompatibility for the leaders and/ or members of IGs
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Stability of legislation (eg. changes too close to elections)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
Extend the practice of requiring the submission of signature lists for the registration of nominated candidates (currently required in presidential elections) to other types of elections.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Stability of legislation (eg. changes too close to elections)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Blocs and coalitions
Recommendation:
Amend the Electoral Code in order to homogenise the rules for establishing electoral blocks in all types of elections. The rules used to nominate candidates for parliamentary elections could serve as a reference.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Structure (clarity, comprehensiveness, codification, consistency)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Campaign regulation
Recommendation:
Change electoral law on the registration of candidates in Moldovan presidential elections to ensure all candidates have an equal amount of time for their election campaigns
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Separation between state and party
Recommendation:
Amend the Electoral Code and the Law on Political Parties in order to establish a method of keeping records and verifying political party membership in order to prevent political activity by members of electoral bodies, and apply sanctions if appropriate.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Structure (clarity, comprehensiveness, codification, consistency)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Legal regulation
Recommendation:
Adjust the Russian version of the Electoral Code to coincide with the Romanian version (for instance, Article 40(1)) in order to avoid any misunderstandings when applying the law.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Voter rights
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of suffrage
Recommendation:
Provide for the participation of students/pupils with the right to vote in the electoral process by applying sustainable and generally applicable provisions for all types of elections.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Structure (clarity, comprehensiveness, codification, consistency)
Recommendation:
Define and explain the phrase “and other socio-political organisations” from the Electoral Code as it relates to the Law on Political Parties.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Overall guarantees of transparency of the electoral process
Recommendation:
Supplement the Law on Personal Data Protection with rules ensuring the transparency and accessibility of voter lists and the transparency of donors’ workplaces in candidates’ financial statements.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Support signatures
Recommendation:
Change the approach to determining the minimum number of signatures on the signature sheets for a second-level administrative territorial unit, both for presidential elections and for other types of elections or referendums. The minimum number should be quantified in percentage values (1% or 2%) relative to the total number of voters from that ATU, rather than in absolute numbers.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Second rounds
Recommendation:
Improve the legal framework by establishing the exact schedule and procedures regulating the continuation of the election campaign to a second round.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Voter identification documents
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Voter identification and documents
Recommendation:
Explicitly regulate the exercise of the right to vote using expired identity documents.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
Eliminate the obligation of candidates for the position of President of the Republic of Moldova to include information about their residence on signature sheets; amend Article 42(3) of the Electoral Code and enforce its provisions for other types of elections and referendums.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
Supplement Article 29(11) of the Electoral Code with provisions on the incompatibility of EOPS membership with the mandate of mayor.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Mandate
Recommendation:
Supplement the Electoral Code with provisions on the status of “Elections” SAIS operators as persons authorised to participate in electoral operations. Regulate the incompatibility of the capacities of observer and party member or elected local official.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Electoral System
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Methods of calculation of votes and seat allocation
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Election procedures (opening, voting, counting, tabulation)
Recommendation:
Amend the legal provisions regulating the method of calculating the percentage value of the votes expressed in support of election candidates in the election of the President of the Republic of Moldova, in order to adjust the formulations for other elections.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Mobile Voting
Recommendation:
Amend the Electoral Code by adjusting the Instructions for the CEC on mobile voting in order to develop a clear mechanism offering voters who vote at their residences equal opportunities for replacing incorrectly-completed ballots just like voters who vote at polling stations.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Impartiality and independence
Recommendation:
Amend Article 27(6) of the Electoral Code to make incompatible the capacities of party member and ECC member nominated by a political party that is in Parliament.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign regulation
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Campaign materials
Recommendation:
Regulate promotional advertising during the signature collection campaign.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Recommendation:
Supplement the regulatory framework in order to clearly regulate the involvement of nonresident service providers in the Republic of Moldova in election campaigns.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Third party campaign financing
Recommendation:
Explicitly regulate the work of private foundations associated with politicians during the election period.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Donations
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Recommendation:
Review the thresholds for donations from individuals and legal entities to election candidates and political parties by reducing them to correspond with the average standard of living.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Recommendation:
Supplement Article 38(1) of the Electoral Code by introducing a clear procedure and schedule for appointing the people responsible for election candidates’ finances (treasurers).
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Recommendation:
Change the legal framework to make ‘Electoral Fund’ bank accounts permanent in order to get rid of uncertainties and possible delays related to opening the accounts.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Paid Advertisement
Recommendation:
Change the legal framework to prohibit paid electoral advertising and to increase free air time from public mass-media institutions, including for broadcasting electoral debates.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Campaign materials
Recommendation:
Change the legal framework to prohibit outdoor electoral advertising (outdoor billboards, city light, mobile panels, posters etc.).
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Donations
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Compliance with international standards and good practice
Recommendation:
Supplement electoral law to limit, prohibit or strictly regulate donations from legal entities that provide goods or services to any public administration, in line with GRECO standards.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Implementation in line with the spirit of the law
Recommendation:
Apply the legal provisions on the punishment of illegal electoral campaign financing, namely Article 181(2) of the Criminal Code, to initiative groups collecting signatures for candidates nominated in a national elections and referendums as well.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Donations
Recommendation:
Change legislation in order to regulate the ability of Moldovan citizens living abroad to fund candidates’ election campaigns.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Donations
Recommendation:
Explicitly regulate the financial accounting for donations both during the election period and in the period between elections, so recording these donations does not burden or delay the work and banking operations of those concerned.
Action required:
Legal change, Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Out-of-Country Voting
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Inclusiveness and Public Consultative Process
Recommendation:
Initiate and organise public discussions on mechanisms for ensuring that voters who are abroad on the day of the election have the right to vote.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Undue / not provided for in law involvement of institutions and bodies (eg. church)
Recommendation:
Sanction the Metropolis of Chisinau and All Moldova for violations of the law by clerics who publicly shared their political preferences and supported a particular candidate during the presidential campaign. Apply sanctions uniformly, in accordance the law, to all religious organisations that were politically involved.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Recommendation:
Ensure more effective and a real-time communication with the external environment, including by updating operatively the institution’s website.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Support signatures
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
Simplify the requirements for compiling IG member lists and the signature sheets. Ensure the transparency of signature sheet verification.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Centralized voter register
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Transparency and accountability
Recommendation:
Conduct a plenary report on the establishment and management of the State Registry of Voters.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Verification and updating of voters lists
Recommendation:
Ensure the continuity and sustainability of the process of verifying lists, as well as their quality.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
Monitor the activity of lower electoral bodies in order to identify incompetent electoral officials. Those officials should be removed from the REO and should not to be involved in electoral activities in subsequent elections.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Use of computerized solutions / technologies in administration
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Centralized voter register
Recommendation:
Ensure the proper functioning of SIAS ‘Elections’.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Secretariat and staff
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Recommendation:
Make more transparent the mechanisms for establishing and filling in the Registry of Electoral Officials
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Persons with disabilities
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Targetted information and materials
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Voter education and information
Recommendation:
Establish a platform for sustainable communication with organisations for people with special needs (hearing, vision, locomotion, etc.) in the RM, in order to inform them about the electoral developments in due time and receive specific requests from them to make the electoral process accessible.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Voter education and information
Recommendation:
Establish mechanisms to ensure that people sentenced to imprisonment have the ability to be informed about election campaigns and election candidates’ platforms just like other citizens.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Operational capacity (funding, staff, equipment)
Recommendation:
Monitoring the implementation of recommendations on the provision of polling station infrastructure.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
Establish a ECC for the polling stations where RM citizens residing in the districts on the left bank of Nistru River (beyond the constitutional control of RM authorities) can exercise their right to vote.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
Check and ensure compliance with legal norms on establishing the electoral offices of polling stations.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Operation in compliance with legal requirements (eg working hours)
Recommendation:
Monitor and ensure compliance with EOPS working hours.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Instructions and regulations
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Campaign materials
Recommendation:
Supplement the Regulation on the Activity of Electoral Offices of Polling Stations with an express provision requiring the electoral body to remove electoral posters within 100 meters of the polling station the day before the election.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance oversight body
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
Conduct an in-depth analysis of the expenses incurred by the IGs and apply appropriate sanctions in case of violations.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Use of state/administrative resources
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Campaign finance oversight body
Recommendation:
Ascertain and evaluate/estimate, in accordance with the guidelines of the Venice Commission, the unauthorized use of administrative resources by political parties or candidates as financial contributions to election campaign funds and report these cases in the appropiate way
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Political Parties and Campaign Oversight Body
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Recommendation:
Establish a more rigorous mechanism for checking the financial statements of election candidates.
Action required:
Legal change, Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
Ensure transparency and accessibility to all data submitted to the CEC by election candidates during the election campaign, including donors’ workplaces, as indicated in the content of the report on campaign financing, by displaying these data on the institution’s website.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Donations
Recommendation:
Reduce the threshold for donations that require verification by the Court of Accounts and the Main State Tax Inspectorate from 75.000 to 50.000, on the basis of reports made available.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
Explicitly regulate the ability of political parties to finance election campaigns so that the identities of primary donors are included in the election candidates’ reports.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Media
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Regulatory Body and Oversight
Recommendation:
Apply sanctions to the mass media in accordance with the law and depending on the severity of infringements. Make media institutions responsible for reporting on the election campaign in an unbiased and fair way.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Roles of institutions of state
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Undue / not provided for in law involvement of institutions and bodies (eg. church)
Recommendation:
Avoid becoming involved in collecting signatures for signature sheets of certain IGs.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Local authorities
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Recommendation:
Avoid using administrative resources and public funds in the interest of a party or to promote certain candidates.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Polling premises
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Operational capacity (funding, staff, equipment)
Recommendation:
Ensure some decent conditions in polling stations during voting: lighting, heating, sanitation, etc
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Local authorities
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Persons with disabilities
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Access to polling stations
Recommendation:
Ensure access for people with special needs (access ramps, polling stations located on the ground floor, etc.).
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Local authorities
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Instructions and regulations
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Access of Observers
Recommendation:
Observe CEC instructions on PS layout in order to provide voters with a clear path and instructions on the conditions for free observation of the electoral process.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Election procedures (opening, voting, counting, tabulation)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Instructions and regulations
Recommendation:
Verify the accuracy of the completion of voting results forms according to the verification formulas embedded in the procedure.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Due process
Recommendation:
Monitor the work of electoral bodies and other election candidates in order to challenge violations in accordance with the law. Raise awareness of the responsibilities of all categories of electoral actors.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Political parties
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Capacity and training
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Capacity (nomination of commission members, proxies, observers, etc.)
Recommendation:
Train supporters (Moldovan citizens with the right to vote) in advance, including them in the electoral process as observers, representatives with the consultative right to vote, and members of lower election bodies with the deliberative right to vote. In this way, frequent changes in the composition of ECC and EOPS will be avoided, and quality monitoring of procedures will be ensured.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Observer organizations, Political parties
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Recommendation:
Do not allow the use of administrative resources for collecting signatures and during election campaigns.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Recommendation:
Cover expenses during signature collection using the bank account meant for Initiative Groups (IGs) only.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Recommendation:
Observe the terms set by electoral authorities when opening the accounts for IGs.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Prohibited sources of funding
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
In-kind donations / services
Recommendation:
Do not use unreported electoral funds and gifts in the period immediately prior to elections.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
Ensure the transparency of revenue collection and expenses during the signature collection period.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
Avoid the transfer of donations from legal entities or parties to the ‘Initiative Group Fund’ and ‘Electoral Fund’ accounts, ensuring transparency of donations and donors.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
Register and report all donations received, including material (in-kind) donations, to the Central Electoral Commission in line with the best practices of the Council of Europe.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
Report all expenses incurred during the election period, in accordance with both the law and the best practices of the Council of Europe.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign materials
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Black PR
Recommendation:
Refrain from using printed materials with denigrating content addressed to rival candidates and from using negative PR in the election campaign.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Undue campaign rethoric (eg. discriminatory, sexist, xenophobic, homophobic campaigning, hate speech)
Recommendation:
Refrain from expressing discriminatory, sexist, xenophobic and homophobic messages and attitudes in the election campaign.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign silence
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Pressure and Intimidation on Voters
Recommendation:
Avoid collective transportation of voters to polling stations on Election Day.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Association Promo - Lex Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
Investigate, in accordance with the provisions of contraventional and criminal law, cases concerning illegal campaign financing, voter corruption and the use of administrative resources for electoral purposes.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Inclusiveness and Public Consultative Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Compliance with international standards and good practice
Recommendation:
In future parliament should approve the electoral laws and amendments thereto involving experts and representatives of non-governmental organisations, to minimise the risk of imperfect laws and as a result their review in process of election campaign.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Operational capacity (funding, staff, equipment)
Recommendation:
The CEC should promptly analyse the causes of difficulties in delays in publication of CEC’ decisions and in access to analytical information system "Vybory" take measures to eliminate them.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Recall or dismissal of election commission members
Recommendation:
In future either the procedure of forming DECs and PECs should be reviewed or the option of replacing committee members on requirement of subjects who nominated them should be limited, due to Candidates for the President being irresponsible in nominations of the DECs' and PECs' members, which is confirmed with a significant number of replacements of DECs' members, because this involves massive confusion in the work.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Legal regulation
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Legal regulation
Recommendation:
In the future, CEC’s role in provision of providing election process security (first of all, coordinative role) should be reinforced, in particular by making amendments to the laws which that regulate CEC powers.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Operational capacity (funding, staff, equipment)
Recommendation:
In the future, legislators should amend the law “On Eelections of the President of Ukraine” to prevent frequent changes the composition in election commissions' composition.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Compliance with international standards and good practice
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Compliance with international standards and good practice
Recommendation:
To properly implement relevant recommendation to electoral legislative concerning election campaigns and information coverage of election.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Recommendation:
To introduce in the electoral law providing impossibility for formation of electoral funds of a party or a candidate by a single person.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
To introduce in the electoral law possibility for parties, which didn't nominate candidates on previous elections but have good chances to overcome the electoral threshold on the early elections, to participate in representation in all electoral commissions.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Recommendation:
To legislatively eliminate inequality in voting rights for voters who stay or resaid not in Ukraine on in election day and who changed their place of voting to another polling station in different single-seat constituency.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Verification and updating of voters lists
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Registration shortly before election day
Recommendation:
To apply procedural provisions of the Law "On Elections of the President of Ukraine" and the Law "On Elections of Deputies of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, local councils and village, town and city mayors" of 2014 regarding direct prohibition of any changes to voter lists on Election Day and elimination of a number of gaps in provisions for election commissions, process of vote tabulation and establishment of election results into the law "On Elections of People's Deputies of Ukraine".
Action required:
Legal change, Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Internally displaced persons (IDPs), labour migrants, other mobile groups of voters
Recommendation:
The status of these internally displaced persons should be set equal to the status of inhabitants of Crimea (as it was done before the election of the President of Ukraine in May 2014), the procedure for changing their place of voting without changing voting address should be simplified.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Recommendation:
Law enforcement bodies should carefully examine cases of violence towards candidates committed by voters and ensure prosecution of persons who organize and/or fulfil illegal activities, as provided by the law.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Voter rights
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of suffrage
Recommendation:
The law should effectively guarantee the electoral rights of ATO participants.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Electoral security
Recommendation:
Тhe law should provide sufficient provisions for securing the security of election commissions, the transportation of election documentation of voting, vote counting and tabulation in areas controlled by the separatists.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Support signatures
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
To unhands CEC’s registration of candidates for People's Deputies of Ukraine with the purpose of giving them equal opportunities to campaign
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Transparency and accountability
Recommendation:
The CEC should take steps to ensure the strict compliance with all requirements of the law on transparency of election commissions activities.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
In the future, the law should provide proportionate and dissuasive sanctions for failure or late submission of financial statements on the receipt and use of election funds, as well as on inclusion false information to these reports. Such reports should also reflect information for the maximum long period before the election (for example, since opening of election funds till the 5th day before the Election Day).
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Operational capacity (funding, staff, equipment)
Recommendation:
To provide budgeting information and education activities of the CEC and local_authoritiesfor IDP’s voting arrangements
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
Organs of Internal Affairs should give proper legal assessment of the tactic of direct and indirect bribery of voters, distributing money, goods, works, and services in person or through a network of activists, and through their own charitable foundations or networks of specifically employed persons ("brigadiers", etc.), taking into account recent legislative changes
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Media
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Paid Advertisement
Recommendation:
After election, the law "On Elections of People's Deputies of Ukraine" should be amended in order to prohibit paid political advertising on television and radio during the election process.
Action required:
Legal change, Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
Destruction or damage of campaign materials on outdoor advertising should be a subject of proper legal assessment and prosecution
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Inclusiveness and Public Consultative Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Compliance with international standards and good practice
Recommendation:
In future parliament should approve the electoral laws and amendments thereto involving experts and representatives of non-governmental organisations, to minimise the risk of imperfect laws and as a result their review in process of election campaign.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Operational capacity (funding, staff, equipment)
Recommendation:
The CEC should promptly analyse the causes of difficulties in delays in publication of CEC’ decisions and in access to analytical information system "Vybory" take measures to eliminate them.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Recall or dismissal of election commission members
Recommendation:
In future either the procedure of forming DECs and PECs should be reviewed or the option of replacing committee members on requirement of subjects who nominated them should be limited, due to Candidates for the President being irresponsible in nominations of the DECs' and PECs' members, which is confirmed with a significant number of replacements of DECs' members, because this involves massive confusion in the work.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Legal regulation
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Legal regulation
Recommendation:
In the future, CEC’s role in provision of providing election process security (first of all, coordinative role) should be reinforced, in particular by making amendments to the laws which that regulate CEC powers.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Operational capacity (funding, staff, equipment)
Recommendation:
In the future, legislators should amend the law “On Eelections of the President of Ukraine” to prevent frequent changes the composition in election commissions' composition.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Implementation in line with the spirit of the law
Recommendation:
To properly implement relevant recommendation to electoral legislative concerning election campaigns and information coverage of election.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Recommendation:
To introduce in the electoral law providing impossibility for formation of electoral funds of a party or a candidate by a single person.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
To introduce in the electoral law possibility for parties, which didn't nominate candidates on previous elections but have good chances to overcome the electoral threshold on the early elections, to participate in representation in all electoral commissions.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Voter rights
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of suffrage
Recommendation:
To legislatively eliminate inequality in voting rights for voters who stay or resaid not in Ukraine on in election day and who changed their place of voting to another polling station in different single-seat constituency.
Action required:
Legal change, Sub-legal change (eg. in regulations and instructions by election management body)
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Verification and updating of voters lists
Recommendation:
To apply procedural provisions of the Law "On Elections of the President of Ukraine" and the Law "On Elections of Deputies of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, local councils and village, town and city mayors" of 2014 regarding direct prohibition of any changes to voter lists on Election Day and elimination of a number of gaps in provisions for election commissions, process of vote tabulation and establishment of election results into the law "On Elections of People's Deputies of Ukraine".
Action required:
Legal change, Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Voter rights
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of suffrage
Recommendation:
The status of these internally displaced persons should be set equal to the status of inhabitants of Crimea (as it was done before the election of the President of Ukraine in May 2014), the procedure for changing their place of voting without changing voting address should be simplified.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Recommendation:
Law enforcement bodies should carefully examine cases of violence towards candidates committed by voters and ensure prosecution of persons who organize and/or fulfil illegal activities, as provided by the law.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Voter rights
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of suffrage
Recommendation:
The law should effectively guarantee the electoral rights of ATO participants.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Electoral security
Recommendation:
Тhe law should provide sufficient provisions for securing the security of election commissions, the transportation of election documentation of voting, vote counting and tabulation in areas controlled by the separatists.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Support signatures
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
To unhands CEC’s registration of candidates for People's Deputies of Ukraine with the purpose of giving them equal opportunities to campaign
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Transparency and accountability
Recommendation:
The CEC should take steps to ensure the strict compliance with all requirements of the law on transparency of election commissions activities.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
In the future, the law should provide proportionate and dissuasive sanctions for failure or late submission of financial statements on the receipt and use of election funds, as well as on inclusion false information to these reports. Such reports should also reflect information for the maximum long period before the election (for example, since opening of election funds till the 5th day before the Election Day).
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Operational capacity (funding, staff, equipment)
Recommendation:
To provide budgeting information and education activities of the CEC and local_authoritiesfor IDP’s voting arrangements
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
Organs of Internal Affairs should give proper legal assessment of the tactic of direct and indirect bribery of voters, distributing money, goods, works, and services in person or through a network of activists, and through their own charitable foundations or networks of specifically employed persons ("brigadiers", etc.), taking into account recent legislative changes
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Media
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Paid Advertisement
Recommendation:
After election, the law "On Elections of People's Deputies of Ukraine" should be amended in order to prohibit paid political advertising on television and radio during the election process.
Action required:
Legal change, Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
Destruction or damage of campaign materials on outdoor advertising should be a subject of proper legal assessment and prosecution
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Inclusiveness and Public Consultative Process
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Compliance with international standards and good practice
Recommendation:
In future parliament should approve the electoral laws and amendments thereto involving experts and representatives of non-governmental organisations, to minimise the risk of imperfect laws and as a result their review in process of election campaign.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Operational capacity (funding, staff, equipment)
Recommendation:
The CEC should promptly analyse the causes of difficulties in delays in publication of CEC’ decisions and in access to analytical information system "Vybory" take measures to eliminate them.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Recall or dismissal of election commission members
Recommendation:
In future either the procedure of forming DECs and PECs should be reviewed or the option of replacing committee members on requirement of subjects who nominated them should be limited, due to Candidates for the President being irresponsible in nominations of the DECs' and PECs' members, which is confirmed with a significant number of replacements of DECs' members, because this involves massive confusion in the work.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Legal regulation
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Legal regulation
Recommendation:
In the future, CEC’s role in provision of providing election process security (first of all, coordinative role) should be reinforced, in particular by making amendments to the laws which that regulate CEC powers.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Operational capacity (funding, staff, equipment)
Recommendation:
In the future, legislators should amend the law “On Eelections of the President of Ukraine” to prevent frequent changes the composition in election commissions' composition.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Implementation in line with the spirit of the law
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Political will
Recommendation:
To properly implement relevant recommendation to electoral legislative concerning election campaigns and information coverage of election.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Recommendation:
To introduce in the electoral law providing impossibility for formation of electoral funds of a party or a candidate by a single person.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
To introduce in the electoral law possibility for parties, which didn't nominate candidates on previous elections but have good chances to overcome the electoral threshold on the early elections, to participate in representation in all electoral commissions.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Voter rights
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of suffrage
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Suffrage rights of citizens abroad
Recommendation:
To legislatively eliminate inequality in voting rights for voters who stay or resaid not in Ukraine on in election day and who changed their place of voting to another polling station in different single-seat constituency.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Verification and updating of voters lists
Recommendation:
To apply procedural provisions of the Law "On Elections of the President of Ukraine" and the Law "On Elections of Deputies of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, local councils and village, town and city mayors" of 2014 regarding direct prohibition of any changes to voter lists on Election Day and elimination of a number of gaps in provisions for election commissions, process of vote tabulation and establishment of election results into the law "On Elections of People's Deputies of Ukraine".
Action required:
Legal change, Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Voter rights
Recommendation:
The status of these internally displaced persons should be set equal to the status of inhabitants of Crimea (as it was done before the election of the President of Ukraine in May 2014), the procedure for changing their place of voting without changing voting address should be simplified.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Recommendation:
Law enforcement bodies should carefully examine cases of violence towards candidates committed by voters and ensure prosecution of persons who organize and/or fulfil illegal activities, as provided by the law.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Voter rights
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of suffrage
Recommendation:
The law should effectively guarantee the electoral rights of ATO participants.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Electoral security
Recommendation:
the law should provide sufficient provisions for securing the security of election commissions, the transportation of election documentation of voting, vote counting and tabulation in areas controlled by the separatists.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Support signatures
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
To unhands CEC’s registration of candidates for People's Deputies of Ukraine with the purpose of giving them equal opportunities to campaign
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Transparency and accountability
Recommendation:
The CEC should take steps to ensure the strict compliance with all requirements of the law on transparency of election commissions activities.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
In the future, the law should provide proportionate and dissuasive sanctions for failure or late submission of financial statements on the receipt and use of election funds, as well as on inclusion false information to these reports. Such reports should also reflect information for the maximum long period before the election (for example, since opening of election funds till the 5th day before the Election Day).
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Operation in compliance with legal requirements (eg working hours)
Recommendation:
To provide budgeting information and education activities of the CEC and local_authoritiesfor IDP’s voting arrangements
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
Organs of Internal Affairs should give proper legal assessment of the tactic of direct and indirect bribery of voters, distributing money, goods, works, and services in person or through a network of activists, and through their own charitable foundations or networks of specifically employed persons ("brigadiers", etc.), taking into account recent legislative changes
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Media
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Paid Advertisement
Recommendation:
After election, the law "On Elections of People's Deputies of Ukraine" should be amended in order to prohibit paid political advertising on television and radio during the election process.
Action required:
Legal change, Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Committee of Voters of Ukraine (CVU) Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
Destruction or damage of campaign materials on outdoor advertising should be a subject of proper legal assessment and prosecution
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election contestants, Parliament, Political parties
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Denial of registration
Recommendation:
It is necessary to exclude the possibility of using administrative resources in collecting signatures, in particular, to prohibit the collection of signatures by unauthorized persons. In addition, it is necessary to provide for the right of observers to be present during the verification of signatures submitted for the nomination of candidates.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ad Hoc Structures Created for Election Period, Authorities (general, broad), Local authorities
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1444514400
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Verification and updating of voters lists
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Public scrutiny
Recommendation:
For the sake of increasing the transparency and accountability of the voter registration process, it is necessary to create a national voter list. Citizens and observers (including election agents, media representatives and international observers) should enjoy full access to the list. Every citizen shall have the right to have access to voter list before voting. In addition, observers should be able to have access to these lists during voting. The number of voters registered at the polling station should be announced by the election commissions before voting and after its completion. It is necessary to create a single register of all voters of the Republic of Belarus.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad), Election Management Body, Parliament
Implementation Status:
In process of implementation
Repeated implementation:
1444514400
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
State funding
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Recommendation:
The Electoral Code allows the CEC to independently administer the state budget funds for the production of information leaflets with the general information about the candidates, instead of financing costs associated with the candidates’ printed campaign materials. This resulted in a low activity of most of the candidates in the production of campaign materials. Therefore, it is necessary to re-enforce at the legislative level the state funding of candidates’ costs of printed campaign materials. This should include the possibility of opening special funds from the moment of registration of nomination groups for the payment of expenses associated with collecting signatures for the nomination of the candidates, by analogy with the presidential election.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad), Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1444514400
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign regulation
Recommendation:
The legislation provides a period of no more than 1 month for the duration of the election campaign. This rule limits both the candidates’ opportunity to campaign and the citizens’ right to obtain full information about the candidates and their election platforms. It is proposed to extend campaigning period for up to at least two months. In addition, it is necessary to discharge the entities in charge of political advertising of any liability for the content of advertising provided by the candidates or political parties.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad), Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1444514400
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Right to logde complaints / appeals
Recommendation:
The Electoral Code provides for a limited list of grounds for submitting appeals to the courts. It is necessary to provide for the possibility of judicial review of any decisions by election commissions and other state bodies in matters relating to elections. First of all, it is necessary to allow the judicial review of decisions of the DECs, which approve the election results
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad), Courts, Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1444514400
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Early or Advance Voting
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Absentee vote certificates
Recommendation:
The procedure for early voting in its current form allows the authorities to carry out various manipulations during the vote count. In this connection, it is proposed to consider the complete abolition of early voting. If early voting is not canceled, it is proposed to introduce criteria, compliance with which gives the voter the right to vote early. Such criteria should be grounds, which clearly prove the impossibility for the voter to vote on Election Day, e.g. a departure abroad or other documented evidence.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad), Parliament
Implementation Status:
Rejected
Repeated implementation:
1444514400
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Early or Advance Voting
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Fraud and irregularities (including attemps of influencing voters)
Recommendation:
The legislation should also specify in detail the procedure for the storage of ballot boxes during early voting and the sealing of the premises where the ballot box is stored. It is necessary to prohibit the presence of unauthorized persons, including police officers, in the voting premises and rooms, in which the ballot boxes, ballots and other election materials are stored. It is also necessary to provide for the right of observers to be present on the premises for voting outside the working hours of election commissions (lunch break, period after the end of voting) in cases when members of the election commissions choose to stay.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ad Hoc Structures Created for Election Period, Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1444514400
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Ballot box stuffing
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Access of observers
Recommendation:
Every PEC should be provided with single-part transparent ballot boxes with plastic tapes for sealing (with individual polling station numbers). Online surveillance throughout the days of early voting should be organized. Every PEC should also be provided with individual seals bearing an individual number. The security of ballots should be provided with corresponding signs.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ad Hoc Structures Created for Election Period, Election Management Body, Local authorities
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1444514400
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Mobile Voting
Recommendation:
It is necessary to determine that the right to mobile voting should be enjoyed by persons with significant health problems (documented by certificates issued by a healthcare institution), which prevent them from arriving at the polling station. The Electoral Code should specify that the citizen’s right to vote under mobile voting procedures only occurs after the transfer to the PEC on Election Day of a written request about the impossibility of voting at the polling station.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad), Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1444514400
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Election procedures (opening, voting, counting, tabulation)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Access of Observers
Recommendation:
The current counting procedure is not transparent. One of the main reasons for this is the absence of a detailed description of the vote counting process in the Electoral Code. In this connection, it is necessary to legislate the following principles of the procedure of vote counting: counting of the votes shall be carried out publicly in the presence of observers who can monitor the accuracy of the voters’ choice on each ballot (i.e. to see the content of each ballot); counting of the votes shall be conducted by one of the commission members, who shall announce the voter’s choice and display each ballot to all the commission members and observers; counting of the votes shall be separate for each ballot box, and the results of separate counting of the votes shall be reflected separately for each ballot box in the final protocol. A copy of the final protocol shall be certified by the chairperson and secretary of the election commission, secured by the commission’s seal and issued to the observers at their request. It is also proposed to legislate the right of observers and candidates’ agents registered with the TECs to attend and observe the procedures for the transfer of ballots and protocols with voting results from the polling stations to the TECs.
Action required:
Legal change, Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ad Hoc Structures Created for Election Period, Authorities (general, broad), Election Management Body, Parliament
Implementation Status:
Rejected
Repeated implementation:
1444514400
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Publication of preliminary and final results
Recommendation:
It is necessary to provide for the possibility of publishing on the website of the CEC of voting results in all electoral districts with separate voting results for each polling station.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body, Parliament
Implementation Status:
Rejected
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Legal Basis to Observe
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Access of Observers
Recommendation:
In order to strengthen confidence in the elections in Belarus, it is necessary to expand the rights of observers through amending electoral legislation. The observers should enjoy the right to access the materials of the commissions relating to its composition, the types of nomination of its members, voter lists, storage of ballots and ballot boxes during early voting, as well as to use video and photo equipment during the implementation of election observation.
Action required:
Legal change, Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ad Hoc Structures Created for Election Period, Election Management Body, Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1444514400
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Effective legal redress
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
Authorities should carry out a thorough investigation of all complaints and violations that took place during all stages of the elections, and hold accountable all responsible persons, including local executive authorities, who interfered in the election process.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Compliance with international standards and good practice
Recommendation:
The recommendations of local and international institutions on the improvement of the Election Code, including those of the Venice Commission of the Council of Europe and the OSCE/ODIHR, should be properly addressed by the government.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1381269600
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Compliance with international standards and good practice
Recommendation:
The pre-election campaign period should be extended.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1381269600
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Roles of institutions of state
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Political will
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Political will
Recommendation:
The current administration should improve its relations with the opposition in order to curb political polarization.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Government
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1381269600
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Fundamental rights and freedoms
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Freedom of association
Recommendation:
All political prisoners should be immediately released and necessary conditions for the free operation of non-government organizations should be established
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Government
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1381269600
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
Election commissions should be formed on the principle of parity with representatives from all political parties
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1381269600
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
Rules for the nomination and registration of candidates should be simplified, and the financial deposit system, an alternative method of candidate registration, should be restored;
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1381269600
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Media
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Access to Media
Recommendation:
All political parties should be guaranteed equal access to the media
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Government
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1381269600
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Fundamental rights and freedoms
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Freedom of assembly
Recommendation:
Serious actions should be undertaken to guarantee the freedoms of assembly, association, and expression.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Government
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1381269600
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
All persons violating the election rights of citizens, particularly the local executive authorities should be held liable for their actions.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Courts
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1446332400
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Compliance with international standards and good practice
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Inclusiveness and Public Consultative Process
Recommendation:
Authorities should take necessary steps for improvement of the Election Code and democratization of election environment in consultation and cooperation with domestic and international organizations.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1446332400
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Fundamental rights and freedoms
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Freedom of assembly
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Political will
Recommendation:
The government should demonstrate political will to restore mutual confidence in relations between the state and public, release all political prisoners, take necessary measures to ensure freedoms of speech, assembly and association, create conducive environment for civil society and political parties to take active, meaningful and free participation in the governance process in order to solve the current political crisis.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Government
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1446332400
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
The election commissions should be formed based on political parity principle in order to ensure their independence.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1446332400
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Right to logde complaints / appeals
Recommendation:
The government should ensure to address the shortcomings in the assessment of the Referendum results, as well as in the Election Code and other relevant legislation including the rules for filing complaints regarding the violation of the election rights.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Government
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1446332400
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Fundamental rights and freedoms
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Freedom of Expression
Recommendation:
Norms of national legislation restricting right to freedom of expression as well as provisions punishing persons on charges of defamation such as blocking of websites should be removed, Seymur Hazi, Afgan Mukhtarli, Mehman Huseynov, journalists, arrested on politically motivated charges should be released.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Government
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1474840800
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Fundamental rights and freedoms
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Freedom of association
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Freedom of assembly
Recommendation:
The serious measures should be taken on ensuring the freedom of assembly and association, legislation restricting operation and financing of civil society organisations and political parties should be improved, 130 persons who are considered political prisoners should be released.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1474840800
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Roles of institutions of state
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Political will
Recommendation:
The government should take measures by building trust between political sides in order to prevent political polarization in the society, ensure participation of public organizations and political groups in administration of state.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Government
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1474840800
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Compliance with international standards and good practice
Recommendation:
The initiatives and recommendations of Venice Commission as well as OSCE/ODIHR should be supported on improving Election Code, election commissions should be formed on the principle of parity with representatives from all political parties.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1474840800
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Verification and updating of voters lists
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Accuracy
Recommendation:
Clear and simple rules on updating voter lists should be put forward, the contradiction between the figures of demographic statistics of people and voter lists should be removed.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1474840800
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Accreditation Requirements and Practice
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Use of computerized solutions / technologies in administration
Recommendation:
Central Election Commission should set out initiatives on online accreditation of observers and lift all restrictions on this matter.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1474840800
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Effective legal redress
Recommendation:
The democratic and advanced rules should be established on filing complaints with the judicial and non-judicial bodies.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1474840800
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
Nomination and registration of candidates should be simplified, the financial deposit system as an alternative method of candidate registration, should be restored.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1474840800
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign regulation
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Access to Media
Recommendation:
Pre-election campaign period should be extended, during interelections and pre-election period access to media should be ensured for all political parties.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1474840800
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Election Monitoring and Democracy Studies Center (EMDS) Primary Thematic Area: Roles of institutions of state
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Political will
Recommendation:
Political will should be demonstrated on the implementation of the judgements of the European Court of Human Rights on violation of right to free elections, those who are responsible for the violation of this right should be held accountable and ousted from their position.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Government
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1474840800
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Impartiality and independence
Recommendation:
The Electoral Code should be amended and the Precinct Commissions should be composed based on the same principle of impartiality of the CEC and TECs where no party member can be included.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Impartiality and independence
Recommendation:
The Precinct Commissions should be composed of residents of different communities (not from the community of the Precinct where they are assigned). This will promote impartiality and fairness.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Election procedures (opening, voting, counting, tabulation)
Recommendation:
The law should clearly define the principle of distribution of roles/functions among Precinct Commission members in every two-hour round on the election day.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Training
Recommendation:
Extensive trainings (preferably, one-month-long) should be provided for members of the Precinct Electoral Commissions (PEC). As a result, they are expected to get well-aware of Electoral Code, CEC decisions and their roles within PECs.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Accreditation Requirements and Practice
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Legal Basis to Observe
Recommendation:
To avoid unnecessary bureaucracy, it should be defined that the CEC decision N°37 is applicable only to those, who have not acquired accreditation according to the CEC decision N°36 (both decisions made on July 29, 2011).
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Recommendation:
The procedures and boundaries of interactions between the PECs and Police should be narrowed down and precised.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Voter rights
Recommendation:
Ballot lists of candidates should include also an option "Against all".
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Impartiality and independence
Recommendation:
The HCAV insists to review the regulations on PEC composition. It recommends that members of PEC should not be related to the communities where the Precinct of their assignment is located.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1329001200
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Accreditation Requirements and Practice
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Accreditation Requirements and Practice
Recommendation:
To withdraw the requirement of taking a qualification exam for being allowed to carry an observation mission and to accredit an organization for observation mission based on its official statute.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Accreditation Requirements and Practice
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Effective legal redress
Recommendation:
Complaints and appeals on electoral violations revealed by observers should be properly addressed and eliminiated despite whose right is violated and who is the applicant.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Accreditation Requirements and Practice
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Legal Basis to Observe
Recommendation:
The law should define that an organisation deploying an observation mission bears the responsibility for engaging quality and unbiased observers and for proper and objective implementation of the mission. The CEC can define administrative sanctions for breaching the principle of observation impartiality by particular observers.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Training
Recommendation:
Precinct Electoral Commissions' members should be provided with extensive and lasting professional trainings to insure their full competence on legal requirements and specificities of electoral process.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Impartiality and independence
Recommendation:
Precinct Electoral Commissions should be composed of members of the other communities rather than where the precinct is located, to reduce illigal influence on election administration and to insure increase of professionalism and impartiality of the electoral process/administration.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Recommendation:
The order of changes (rotation?) of PEC members should be clearly defined and met the law requirements.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Unauthorized persons / interference
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Election procedures (opening, voting, counting, tabulation)
Recommendation:
The law forsee who can be in precinct during vote counting and resuling the results but it should also clarify when and how they can enter a precinct. There is a gap on this in the law.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Ballot content
Recommendation:
The line "Against All" should be added to the list of candidates in ballots of all local (municipal) and national suffrages regardless of the number of candidates and should start being considered as valid.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Supplementary and special voters lists
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Absentee vote certificates
Recommendation:
Lists of absent voters should be composed separately from general list of voters. Citizens from the Absent Voters List should vote according to the same regulations provided for diplomatic staffs and their families, as well as for those of legal persons registered in Armenia and residing in abroad. The Absent Voters' List should be published/posted in the precincts of their registered residence.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Supplementary and special voters lists
Recommendation:
Instead of separating and classifying the voting lists of military servicemen, their names should be disperse in general lists of voters in order to prevent multiple voting through additional lists.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Helsinki Citizen's Assembly - Vanadzor Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Turnout
Recommendation:
The signed lists of voters should be published after the vote to let the public see who has indeed voted.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
International Observation
Recommendation:
International Observation Missions (IOMs) should analyse the schemes of electoral fraud profoundly in order to offer more efficient recommendations.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
International observer organizations
Repeated implementation:
1438120800
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
International Observation
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Methods of calculation of votes and seat allocation
Recommendation:
IOMs should advocate for publishing the signed lists of voters participated in the vote after the vote.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
International observer organizations
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Repeated implementation:
1438120800
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
International Observation
Recommendation:
The IOMs should constantly and closely collaborate with domestic observation organisations (DOO) when working on recommendations.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
International observer organizations
Repeated implementation:
1438120800
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
International Observation
Recommendation:
The IOMs should advocate for CEC's more proactive role in checking the documents introduced to them.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
International observer organizations
Repeated implementation:
1438120800
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
International Observation
Recommendation:
Based on the HCAV's analysis of the implementation of OSCE/ODIHR previous recommendations on elections in Armenia, a list of not-implemented or inefficiently implemented recommendations should be composed and [missed word] with the Armenian Government for their implementation.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
International observer organizations
Repeated implementation:
1438120800
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Compliance with international standards and good practice
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Overall guarantees of transparency of the electoral process
Recommendation:
The Standing Committee of State and Legal Affairs (SCSLA) of the National Assembley (NA is the Parliament of Armenia) should insure the implementation of the IOMs' recommendations on elections (including referenda) in Armenia in 2003-2013 on legislative level.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Repeated implementation:
1438120800
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
The NA SCSLA should stipulate in the law that the CEC is obliged to check and verify the grounds of documents provided by the candidates, including those related to citizenship and residency, income declarations, reports on electoral campaign expenses.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Legal Basis to Observe
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Right to logde complaints / appeals
Recommendation:
The Parliament should recover the rights of observer organisations of lodging complaints against the electoral breaches and vote results.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Recommendation:
The legislation should clearly formulate the duties and obligations of the law-inforcement bodies, especially those of the police, for preventing frauds and irregularities, including on the day of elections.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Voting abroad
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Suffrage rights of citizens abroad
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Out-of-Country Voting
Recommendation:
To insure the voting rights of Armenian citizens residing abroad through voting in embassies and consulates.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Public confidence
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Recommendation:
The legislation should insure publication of the participated voters' signed lists on the CEC website within three days after elections.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Legal Basis to Observe
Recommendation:
To recover the legal provision that excludes any persecution for observers expressing their opinion about the electoral process
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Polling premises
Recommendation:
To prescribe the function of preventing electoral fraud and irregularities beyond 50 meters perimeter away around precincts to the electoral commissions, particularly to the TECs and the CEC.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Accreditation Requirements and Practice
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Capacity and training
Recommendation:
To withdraw the requirement of taking a qualification exam for being allowed to carry an observation mission and to define that an organsation observing elections is responsible for recruiting quality and impartial observers.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Access of Observers
Recommendation:
To withdraw the provision that requires to deprive an organsation of its right to carry on an observation mission if one of its observers breaches the law.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Repeated implementation:
1336255200
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Proxies and party representatives
Recommendation:
Registering the proxies by CEC beforehead the vote should be required by the Electoral Code.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Recommendation:
The CEC should insure proper implementation of the IOMs' recommendations on the election administration.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Supplementary and special voters lists
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Verification and updating of voters lists
Recommendation:
The names of citizens being abroad at least five days before the voting day should compose a separate list from the general lists of voters.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations
Recommendation:
Insists on the recommendations made following the latest parliamentary elections two months before.
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Repeated implementation:
1491084000
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
The law should define a reasonable volume/limit of electoral irregularities and frauds, particularly about vote buying and abuse of administrative resources, that may cause annulation of registration of a candidate or party and of vote results.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Effective legal redress
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Timeframes
Recommendation:
The final decision about the voting results should be taken only after a reasonable timeframe for due investgation of electoral fraud and irregularities.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Procedures (Effective, Clear, Formalized)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Timeframes
Recommendation:
Ammendments to the Electoral Code are recommended for regulation of urgent administration, such as launching a hotline and addressing complaints and appeals to electoral commissions via email.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Electoral System
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Type of electoral system
Recommendation:
Separation between national and regional [candidates']lists should be irradicated and a purely proportional electoral system should be launched.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Roles of institutions of state
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Undue / not provided for in law involvement of institutions and bodies (eg. church)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Recommendation:
A general restriction of abuse of admnistrative resources should be fixed according to the Venice Commission's recommendation and the consequences should be defined clearly.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Voter rights
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Restrictions on the right to vote
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Suffrage rights of citizens abroad
Recommendation:
Realization of the right to vote of Armenian citizens who are abroad on the voting day should be guaranteed through Armenian diplomatic institutions abroad.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
Organization and implementation of mass electoral fraud and irregularities should be considered as a grave crime against state and against the Constitution (Art. 2) and relevant punishment should be defined.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Structure (clarity, comprehensiveness, codification, consistency)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Legal regulation
Recommendation:
The Electoral Code should define more precisely the provisions on administrative and criminal sanctions.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance oversight body
Recommendation:
The status of the Oversight and Audit Service (OAS) of the CEC should be changed. The OAS should be entitled to oversight validity of reports about incomes, donations and expenses for electoral campaigns, in declarations submitted by candidates and parties.
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Right to logde complaints / appeals
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Legal Basis to Observe
Recommendation:
The right of observers to file complaints and appeals against electoral fraud and results should be recovered.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Legal Basis to Observe
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Pressure and Intimidation on Journalists
Recommendation:
The article 32.1.6 of the current Electoral Code should be completed with the content of the Article 30.6 of the EC of 1999 according to which, observers and media representatives cannot be held responsible for their opinions expressed regarding the electoral process and counting results.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Structure (clarity, comprehensiveness, codification, consistency)
Recommendation:
Terms "precinct", "polling station" and "voting premises" should be defined clearly.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Polling premises
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Access to polling stations
Recommendation:
Additional measures should be taken to insure full accessibility of both voting premises and of voting procedures to minimalize the need of help by another person and to ensure direct and secret voting by voters.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sessions of commissions
Recommendation:
All the functions of Territorial Electoral Committees should be performed in a single room in presence of all the TEC members.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sessions of commissions
Recommendation:
Legal status should be prescribed to employees of TECs who are present at sessions/hearings.
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Electoral System
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Type of electoral system
Recommendation:
Mix electoral system should be changed with the fully proportional system.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
Revise the rules of composition of all three tiers of the election administration. Preference should be given to professionalization of the administration and selection of members based on qualifications.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
Introduction of mandatory certification requirement for PEC members.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
Number of members in electoral commissions should be reduced to enable hiring of qualified individuals in election administration.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign regulation
Recommendation:
Agitation must be defined as including both active and passive agitation. Which includes attending meetings during pre-election campaign.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Separation between state and party
Recommendation:
Deputy Ministers and Governers should not have rigth to participate in pre-election campaign during working hours.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance oversight body
Recommendation:
Head and deputy head of the State Audit Office should not be nominated to any elective position, should not be political party members and political officials during a certain perdio prior to occupying the post and three years after the expiration of authority.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Bribing and distribution of inducements to voters
Recommendation:
Harmonize the definition of vote buying provided in different legal acts.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Bribing and distribution of inducements to voters
Recommendation:
Vote buying with more than 300 GEL should be punishable under Criminal Code.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Bribing and distribution of inducements to voters
Recommendation:
Criminal liability of a voter should be excluded in case of vote buying. An administrative liability should be imposed on an object of vote buying for receiving any illegal benefit if s/he engaged in such action wittingly; s/he should be relieved of liability after confessing the fact.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Timeframes
Recommendation:
1. The deadline for appealing should be calculated from the date the decision of the DEC was submitted to the complainant as opposed to the day the decision was delivered. 2. The decision of DEC must be submitted to the parties before 12pm the day following the decision.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Right to logde complaints / appeals
Recommendation:
Redefine categories of claimants so that it allowas local monitoring organizations to file all types of complaints envisaged by Article 78 of the Election Code.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Procedures (Effective, Clear, Formalized)
Recommendation:
In view of short deadlines for appealing election disputes to the court the High Council of Justcie should be required to design special forms of complaints for election disputes.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Courts, Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Women
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Women in political parties and as candidates
Recommendation:
To promote women’s participation in politics, legislation should provide for a temporary mandatory gender quotas for party lists.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Legal regulation
Recommendation:
Military personnel should be able to vote in majoritarian elections according to their address of registration.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Legal regulation
Recommendation:
The military should vote in ordinary polling stations, according to their place of registration. In order to do so, they should apply to the relevant PEC 16 days in advance. If a member of the military cannot vote in their ordinary polling station because, for instance, s/he is unable to return home on Election Day, s/he may vote in a civilian polling station nearest to his/her duty station.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Legal regulation
Recommendation:
Establishment of special polling stations should only be allowed under strictly exceptional circumstances, e.g., when a member of the military is on active duty and therefore, unable to leave his/her military unit.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign regulation
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
New Media
Recommendation:
Definition of campaigning should comprise also campaigning on social media. It should be also specified that campaigning by civil servants during work hours, using personal social media accounts amounts to violation.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Recommendation:
Participation of employees of all budgetary organizations in campaigning during working hours should be prohibited.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign regulation
Recommendation:
With regard to charitable organizations it should be established that for purposes of the Election Code, an organization is considered charitable whether or not it is registered with the tax agency as a charitable organization.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign regulation
Recommendation:
the person that organized participation of an alien in campaigning should be subjected to liability.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Right to logde complaints / appeals
Recommendation:
The Election Code must clearly stipulate that any observer of an organization with observer status has the right to file a complaint concerning violations that other observers of the organization detected and filed a complaint about.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Right to logde complaints / appeals
Recommendation:
There should not be such clear distinction and an organization with observer status should be able to be named as a claimant in all disputes where under the applicable legislation only its representative has the right to file a complaint in court.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Legal redress by courts
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Right to logde complaints / appeals
Recommendation:
DECs should take into account final decisions of all levels of court when summarizing polling results.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Right to logde complaints / appeals
Recommendation:
The Election Code should directly define the possibility to appeal in court refusal of the CEC chair and of authorized representatives (officials) of the CEC and relevant DEC to draw up a protocol of administrative offences.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Results protocols
Recommendation:
Not only commission members but also all individuals present at the polling station when the summary protocol was prepared should be summoned to attend the meeting for drawing up amendment protocols the day after Polling Day.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Recounts
Recommendation:
The law should define cases when it is mandatory for an electoral commission to review electoral documentation and recount election results. DECs should be obligated to revise voting results in cases when: number of votes received by subjects, number of voters, or number of invalid ballots has been overwritten in a summary protocol; the sum of number of votes received by subjects and the number of invalid ballots exceeds the number of votes cast in the election.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
To ensure that disciplinary violations are responded, if a complaint is filed against a PEC member his/her term of office should be extended until the final decision about their disciplinary liability is made. Extension of the term does not require paying the PEC member for the extended period
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Mobile Voting
Recommendation:
A voter should be entered into the mobile ballot box list solely based on applications of the voter himself/herself or his/her family member. The application should be provided to relevant PEC by the voter himself/herself or his/her family member. No one but the voter or his/her family member should be allowed to file a request with a PEC on behalf of the voter for his/her inclusion in the mobile ballot box list. In addition, a telephone call may not serve as the legal basis for entering a voter into the mobile ballot box list. If a voter is unable to visit polling station and he/she has no family, based on a notification received over the phone or by any other means, relevant PEC should verify the need to include the voter into the mobile ballot box list and make subsequent decision.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Secrecy of voting
Recommendation:
The law should prescribe responsibility for violating ballot secrecy. Voters that violate ballot secrecy should also be held liable.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Fraud and irregularities (including attemps of influencing voters)
Recommendation:
A sanction for violating the prohibition of gambling on elections should be established and also the body responsible for imposing a sanction
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
The rule for holding a competition to select professional members of DECs and PECs, applicable objective criteria and procedures should be prescribed in detail, in order to establish the standard of fairness and transparency for the competition. Open interviews should be one of the mandatory stages of the competition.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body, Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Sessions of commissions
Recommendation:
To improve transparency and accountability of the election administration, live streaming of CEC and DEC meetings through social media and/or on websites should be introduced.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Campaign finance oversight body
Recommendation:
The State Audit Office should design effective methodology for monitoring election campaign on social media and for taking effective actions in response to illegal donations.
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Political Parties and Campaign Oversight Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Media
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Access to Media
Recommendation:
Opportunity of airing a political advertisement during non-electoral period and applicable regulations should be determined by law.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
State funding
Recommendation:
Recipients of all types of budgetary funding – both direct and indirect funding – should technically become electoral subjects, which means that one electoral subject, regardless of whether it is a party or an electoral bloc, should receive one equal portion of funding. 
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
State funding
Recommendation:
Electoral subjects should receive funding based on the results of the last parliamentary and/or local government elections. The so-called mixing of components should only be allowed if the electoral subject concerned overcame the 3% threshold in both elections. 
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: International Society for Fair Elections and Democracy (ISFED) Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
State funding
Recommendation:
Additional funding for creation of a faction in the Parliament should be abolished.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Recommendation:
It is necessary to reconsider the system of forming precinct electoral commissions and their activities, eliminating political and other dependencies, simultaneously clarifying responsibilities. It is preferable that PECs be formed on the principles of TECs on the basis of standards defined by law and be appointed by the CEC. Such a mechanism will contribute to improving the professional quality of commissions and the assurance of integrated application of CEC guidelines
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Electoral System
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Type of electoral system
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Districts and constituencies
Recommendation:
The district electoral lists should be terminated and the electoral procedure as a whole should be brought to the format of proportional elections, which will significantly limit or minimize the direct motivation and probability of actions aimed at providing votes in favor of their party by businessmen or those having other levers of influence through vote-buying, pressure and threats.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Roles of institutions of state
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Separation of party and state
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Recommendation:
Regulations limiting the use of administrative resources should be tightened and adequate liability measures defined to prevent distortion of competition due to the misuse of administrative resources. Any case of using public resources by a candidate to serve the interests of a political party or other private interests must be seen as reprehensible, with ensuing legal consequences, revoking the registration of a particular political force or particular candidate in question
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Supplementary and special voters lists
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Legal regulation
Recommendation:
The issues related to voter lists must be resolved fundamentally, once and for all. In particular, it is necessary to review the mechanism of forming the voter register, separating citizens who are living in Armenia and those who are living abroad. As an alternative to this, we consider it appropriate to introduce a mechanism of clearing the lists through a preregistration system, prescribed by the RA law of June 30 2016 “On Making Amendments and Additions to the Electoral Code of the Republic of Armenia”, but the law was never implemented, with the excuse of time constraints and technical difficulties given
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Centralized voter register
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Voter identification and documents
Recommendation:
It is also necessary to ensure the use of the legislative and technical possibility of matching fingerprints collected with the help of technical devices.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Media
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Pressure and Intimidation on Journalists
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Pressure and Intimidation on Observers
Recommendation:
Regulations introduced by the new EC related to limitations on the rights of observers and media representatives should be reconsidered, in particular, removing restrictions on the number of media representatives accredited, the right of the PEC to remove an observer or a media representative from the precinct, restriction on the right to present observations on the voting procedure, as well as the discriminatory privileges for terrestrial on-air broadcasting media representatives.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Legal Basis to Observe
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Right to logde complaints / appeals
Recommendation:
At the same time, to ensure a more effective electoral process, observers and organizations carrying out observation missions, in addition to the opportunity to record their assessments of electoral violations in the registration book of the precinct, should also be entitled to appeal the decisions, actions or inactions of the electoral commissions related to those violations, as well as to dispute the results of the voting in the precinct. Observation organizations that assume responsibility for their observers should also be entitled to protect their violated rights through judicial proceedings
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
International Observation
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Accreditation Requirements and Practice
Recommendation:
The right to invite international NGOs should be provided not only to state agencies but also to NGOs. It will eliminate demonstrations of arbitrariness by the CEC and other competent agencies sending invitations and will contribute to enhancing the quality of public oversight, strengthening cooperation with professional observation organizations. The CEC can reject the registration of an international observation organization only if the organization does not meet the specific standards prescribed by law.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Transparency and accountability
Recommendation:
The format of the "open data" publication as well as live broadcast of sessions on the CEC official website should be stipulated as a requirement by legal framework.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
Criteria and procedures should be envisaged in terms of formation of Election Commissions, to prevent involvement of persons who have previously demonstrated unlawful behavior.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Recommendation:
It is necessary to take measures to enhance transparency of Territorial Election Commissions work, for example by means of posting on the CEC website relevant section the TEC sessions timetable, agendas, protocols, video records and resolutions, as well as declarations of asset and income of candidates running in the local self-government elections.
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Procedures (Effective, Clear, Formalized)
Recommendation:
Territorial Election Commissions should have an online grievance system and/or an e-mail address to accept applications and complaints executed by electronic signature.
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Training
Recommendation:
Territorial Commissions should undergo regular training, providing professional development and forming appropriate motivation to act professionally.
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Training
Recommendation:
It is necessary to improve the processes and the methodology of recruitment, selection and training of the Precinct Commission members.
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Impartiality and independence
Recommendation:
It is necessary to reconsider the mechanism of formation of Precinct Election Commissions on party basis, by replacing it with a public-service system-based mechanism, which will ensure more qualified, unbiased and responsible work of Commission members.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Accuracy
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Verification and updating of voters lists
Recommendation:
It is necessary to take measures to correct and enhance the integrity of voter register and lists, by revising mechanisms of their formation. Possible solutions may include: temporary exclusion from voter lists of citizens with expired validity passports and/or voter pre-registration 3-6 months before the elections.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Accuracy
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Verification and updating of voters lists
Recommendation:
There is an urgent necessity to finalize clarification of voter addresses, including: segregating multiple households registered at the same address and allocating unique addresses to voters without address. Clarification of addresses and citizens re-registration processes should be carried out at the expense of state or community budgets.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Centralized voter register
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Safeguards against multiple registration
Recommendation:
Technical devices for voters’ registration should be integrated into a single online system, to track voter turnout throughout the entire Republic of Armenia, or otherwise provide for real time comparison of voter names and exclusion of multiple voting.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Equality of campaign opportunities
Recommendation:
It is necessary to clarify the term of the pre-election campaign and the period of the preelection campaign. It should be ensured that the campaigning rules for political parties (party alliances) and candidates, including restrictions on the use of administrative resources, extend to longer period than the officially established pre-election campaign timeline, to ensure equal access to public resources.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign regulation
Recommendation:
It is necessary to set mechanisms for proper control over campaign rules as well as to take effective measures to prevent and eliminate violations of campaign rules.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign regulation
Recommendation:
It is necessary to clarify and strengthen the liability for infringement of pre-election campaign rules envisaged by law, as well as to empower and provide instruments to relevant authorities (such as Election Commissions, local self-governance authorities, etc.) to effectively penalize political parties (party coalitions) for infringements of election campaign procedures and rules.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign materials
Recommendation:
Responsibility for removing campaign materials posted on the walls after the Election Day should be assigned to the political parties (party alliances) running in the elections.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Legal regulation
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Recommendation:
Electoral legislation should define the terms of administrative resource and its abuse, as well as clarify the limit of legitimate use and misuse of administrative resources throughout the electoral process.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Legal regulation
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Recommendation:
It is necessary to set more stringent legislative regulations limiting the use of administrative resources and to establish adequate sanctions - up to the invalidation of the registration of the relevant political party or the candidate.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Training
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Recommendation:
It is necessary to introduce and implement appropriate training programs/resource materials aimed at raising awareness among public servants regarding the administrative resource and the risks inherent to its abuse.
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Electoral System
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Districts and constituencies
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Recommendation:
It is necessary to abandon the electoral system with territorial lists of political parties (party alliances), which will make financing more transparent, limit the misuse of administrative resources, and reduce the potential influence of business and criminal authorities on electoral processes.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
New Media
Recommendation:
Expenses incurred by political parties (party alliances) in relation to social media advertising should be included in the Declaration and compare them with the information obtained through the official inquiries made to authorities managing the respective social networks
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Recommendation:
In funds declarations, within the expenditures items the requirement for separation/ classification of goods and services should be clarified. 85
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Third party campaign financing
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Prohibited sources of funding
Recommendation:
It is necessary to provide adequate control and liability mechanisms for third party funding. 86
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Media
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Media Ownership
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Regulatory Body and Oversight
Recommendation:
It is necessary to undertake actions to ensure publicity and proper oversight over financial sources and real owners of mass media.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance oversight body
Recommendation:
The framework of OAS competencies should be revised, through providing OAS proper resources and tool to comprehensively supervise finance activities of political parties, including incomes and expenditures of pre-election funds of political parties (party alliances), accuracy of data included in declarations and their compliance with requirements of the RA legislation. It is also necessary to consider the relevance of defining additional guarantees to ensure more effective and independent operation of OAS.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Accreditation Requirements and Practice
Recommendation:
It is necessary to improve and simplify the observer accreditation system, which will improve the efficiency of the process and reduce the cost both for observation missions and for the CEC perspective. The capacities of state-of-the art information exchange and communication technologies should be effectively utilized. 87
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Accreditation Requirements and Practice
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Partisan Observation
Recommendation:
There is a need to expand the list of grounds for rejecting an observer's accreditation request by ensuring that a non-governmental organization that publicly supports any "fake" or political force is not included in the list of observer organizations. It is also necessary to envisage mechanisms for revision and revocation of accreditation for such organizations and certificates of observers after the accreditation has taken place
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Accreditation Requirements and Practice
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
International Observation
Recommendation:
It is necessary to clarify the requirements for international organizations or foreign observer organizations, in particular, the grounds for rejecting the applications or not sending invitations in the case when they have submitted an application to carry out observation mission.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Accreditation Requirements and Practice
Recommendation:
It is necessary to reconsider the non-legitimate regulations limiting the rights of observers and mass media as defined by the RA Electoral Code, including the application of a digital restrictions.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Pressure and Intimidation on Observers
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Partisan Observation
Recommendation:
The possibility of removing observers from polling stations by precinct electoral commissions should be limited exclusively to the instances where they explicitly demonstrate politically biased behavior. 88
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Media
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Impartiality and Independence
Recommendation:
For mass media, the discriminatory privileges for media outlets carrying out on-site broadcasting should be eliminated. It is also necessary to eliminate the digital restriction for mass media representatives.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Persons with disabilities
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Access to polling stations
Recommendation:
It is necessary to undertake steps to ensure that voters with physical disabilities participate in the voting by preparing specifically accessible polling stations.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Impartiality and independence
Recommendation:
In the case of violation of the procedure established by the legislation, the right of the Commission member, proxy and observer to make a record in the logbook89 should be extended to cover not only on the voting procedure but also the voting preparation and result summarization stages.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Legal redress by EMBs
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Right to logde complaints / appeals
Recommendation:
In case of violation of the law, Commission members, proxies and observers should be empowered to request their remarks to be recorded in the logbook and introduce a logbook maintenance practice in the Territorial Election Commissions as well.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Use of computerized solutions / technologies in administration
Recommendation:
It is necessary to ensure free access to the Election Day video-recordings at the CEC website for a certain period, at least until the expiry of the deadline for challenging election results, to ensure further investigations. Moreover, video recordings should contain the number of polling station and time, as well be available for download. It is desirable to replace silent video surveillance with cameras having voice recording capabilities that will include the number of the polling station and record the timing chronology.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Legal Basis to Observe
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Right to logde complaints / appeals
Recommendation:
The RA Electoral Code should acknowledge the legal standing of observer organizations in cases of violations of observers subjective rights deriving from their status, which will help to protect the violated rights of the observer who has been recruited, accredited and trained by the organization and acting on the organizations behalf.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Right to logde complaints / appeals
Recommendation:
Observers and observer organizations should be entitled to appeal against decisions, actions or inactions of Election Commissions in relation to violations of the objective electoral right, as well as dispute the outcome of the voting results in a polling station.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Timeframes
Recommendation:
It is necessary to revise the legal regulation on the timing and procedure established by the RA Electoral Code for appealing and for decision-making by Election Commissions90 and to ensure that the CEC should review the appeals lodged against the resolutions of the Territorial Election Commissions prior to the summarization of the election results.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Timeframes
Recommendation:
It is necessary to revise deadlines and formats of the application-complaint, considering the option of electronic filing of complaints, as well as to revise the list of required documents, and deadlines for finalization of the elections and summarizing the results, which will allow sufficient time for adequate investigation and resolution for election disputes.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Capacity and training
Recommendation:
It is necessary to eliminate the requirement for state duty payment for the organizations carrying out public oversight of election processes.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Secrecy of voting
Recommendation:
To ensure the secrecy of vote (which is not only a right but also an obligation of a voter), the Article 5 of Electoral Code should be completed with a sentence: "It is forbidden to photo or to demonstrate one's ballot".
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Secrecy of voting
Recommendation:
The Article 65 forbids a voter to say in precinct for who they have voted. The articl must be ammended so that announcing about it was forbidden also before voting.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Election procedures (opening, voting, counting, tabulation)
Recommendation:
The Article 66 should include the following: "The vote mark in the ballot should be made by a blue-ink pen provided in all booths.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Secrecy of voting
Recommendation:
The Article 68 should be completed with the following sentence: "7) if the vote mark is done with a color not defined by law".
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Bribing and distribution of inducements to voters
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Polling premises
Recommendation:
The EC Article 18, provision 7 forbids the electoral steakholders to provide or to promise, personally or in their names, any goods or services to the voters. The Article should also state that it is "forbidden to organize dinner/lunch in precinct premises for the PEC members and persons legally permited to be present in the precinct premises".
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Election procedures (opening, voting, counting, tabulation)
Recommendation:
The EC Article 63 should be completed to provide that pauses for having food are taken without interumpting the voting process.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Election procedures (opening, voting, counting, tabulation)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Polling premises
Recommendation:
The Article 40.10 provision 1 of the Administrative Breaches' Code should be ammended, too, in order to forbid "organizing dinner for PEC members and present persons in the precinct premises".
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Right to logde complaints / appeals
Recommendation:
Although an observer can present their findings to the Head of the PEC, the Head is obliged to take measures to address such reports introduced only by the PEC members and proxies, not by journalists and observers. Hence, we propose to amend the EC Article 66 provision 6 as following: "proxies or observers".
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Results protocols
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Election materials
Recommendation:
The EC Article 67 provision 7 should be amended for providing calculation of those envelopes and ballotes that are different from the confirmed sample, when found during summing up the final results. This will allow to disclose "carousel" or other freuds.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Results protocols
Recommendation:
To stop covering up "carousel" or other freuds, the EC Article 72 should provide that the number of inaccuracies should be written down as it is and not as zero according to the current EC.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Results protocols
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Unauthorized persons / interference
Recommendation:
The EC Article 67 should be amended and the word "voters" should be removed to make sure that entering the precinct premises after the official time of voting (20:00) is forbidden to everyone, not only to voters.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Legal regulation
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Legal redress by EMBs
Recommendation:
The Criminal Code provides that a head of PEC can be criminally charged if their actions or inactions make summing up of voting results impossible, but not for (in)actions before the sum up of results. We propose to amend the Administrative Breaches' Code Article 40.06 to impose responsibility over PEC Heads for their (in)actions during the entire process of the PEC's functioning.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Timeframes
Recommendation:
The EC Articles 46 & 48 should be ammended so that the timeframe for filing complaints is prolonged up to three days (currently complaints can be filed to the TECs only on the voting day and on the next day from 12:00 to 18:00).
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Right to logde complaints / appeals
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Citizen Observation
Recommendation:
Although an observer is accredited through their respective NGO, in practice, many NGOs are refused the right of filing complaint for (in)actions faced by their individual observers. The EC Article 46 should be amended and it should clearly state the right of NGOs to file complaints for their observers.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Public confidence
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Overall guarantees of transparency of the electoral process
Recommendation:
The provision providing that signed lists of voters (voter lists where signs every voter who comes to vote) "must not be published, copied, photoed, or filmed" must be removed from the EC Article11, as far as some cases are disclosed when they vote instead of absent voters (absent from the country).
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Coalition of organizations Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Use of computerized solutions / technologies in administration
Recommendation:
Although all the persons officially allowed to be present in the precinct are legally allowed to make photo, video and audio records, still live video broadcasting from each precinct is extremely recommended. Thus, the EC Article 55 should provide that at least one camera should broadcast from each precinct, without breaching the secrecy of vote.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Support signatures
Recommendation:
The procedure of collecting signatures requires thorough review and modification. The requirement to collect 3% of signatures of constituency voters seems to be overly inflated and is actually a prohibitory threshold preventing candidates from running for the election if they do not obtain considerable financial, organizational, and administrative resources
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Recommendation:
The deliberate efforts should be allocated in order to achieve the greater information transparency regarding the activities of election commissions. The information resources of the election commissions must fully comply with the principles and the legal provisions on the duties of federal and municipal authorities in respect to information dissemination, as well as their work with citizens.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
One of the possible pre-conditions for a preservation of a competitive and fair election and an increase of trust in it, could be the different approach towards the composition of election commissions of  the federal constituent territories, the territorial election commissions, and the municipal commissions by strengthening the role of political parties, not only the ‘parliamentary’ ones, and respectively, by reducing the control over the activities of regional administrative commissions.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Rejected
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Early or Advance Voting
Recommendation:
One of the peculiarities of the 2014 elections was the re-introduction of early voting. In many regions, the fraudulent activities were reported when administratively-dependent voters were forced to cast their vote on early voting days; it violated the principle of free election. This method empowered unfair candidates to safeguard a competitive advantage promising a victory already before the election day. Golos recommends to carefully analyze the irregularities and violations of the early voting procedures as well as to develop mechanisms in order to preclude from them during the next election.
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Stability of legislation (eg. changes too close to elections)
Recommendation:
To facilitate stable electoral laws, to stipulate safeguards from manipulations in favor of the ruling party or individual subjects taking part in the political processes. Any amendments to the election law should primarily respect the interests of the voters
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Citizen Observation
Recommendation:
To facilitate the necessary conditions for citizen election observation, in particular, to provision election observation carried out by public associations
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Impartiality and independence
Recommendation:
To deprive executive institutions and officials of possibility to influence the composition of election commissions
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad)
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
To increase fines for administrative offenses, such as violations of election law and to deprive the perpetrators of these offenses of the right to work for any election commission for 5 years
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
To cancel the requirement for candidates to collect signatures of members of municipal councils in the Gubernatorial Elections or to reduce the threshold up to 1-3% in order to ensure competetive elections
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Support signatures
Recommendation:
To cancel the requirement for candidates to collect voters' signatures in the Elections to Legislative and Representative bodies of regional and local_authoritiesor to reintroduce the electoral deposit in the elections
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Recommendation:
To oblige the heads of regions and municipalities, running for elections, to go on vacation for the period of the election campaign
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Recommendation:
To increase penalties for election officials abusing their powers during the elections and to ensure the inevitability of punishment
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
State funding
Recommendation:
To eliminate any possibility for officials to take advantage of public events organized using public funds and (or) while carrying out their official duties for campaigning purposes
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Donations
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
State funding
Recommendation:
To amend the Russian electoral law by fully depriving all the companies owned by foreign entities or the Russian Federation, Subjects of the Russian Federation or municipalities to contribute to the election funds
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Decision making
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Recommendation:
To guarantee fully independent, impartial, collegial, open and transparent decision-making process, as required by the current electoral law
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Impartiality and independence
Recommendation:
To refrain from being guided by the recommendations and unofficial orders that do not comply with the current electoral law
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Impartiality and independence
Recommendation:
To ensure greater protection of commission members refusing to commit fraudulent actions
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Decision making
Recommendation:
To preclude arbitrary and selective decision making
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of campaign opportunities
Recommendation:
To ensure the equality of all candidates and parties while nominating or registering their candidacies, collecting and verifying voters' signatures, as well as running the election campaign or other electoral activities
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of campaign opportunities
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Access to Media
Recommendation:
To facilitate the best possible environment for candidates' and parties' equal access to media
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Media
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Equality of campaign opportunities
Recommendation:
To develop a set of measures in order to detect and prevent covert campagning carried out under the guise of dissemination of information on the candidate's official duties
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Use of state/administrative resources
Recommendation:
To tighten control over the campaigning events carried out not only at the expense of election funds, though actually benefiting from administrative resources and unequal access to media
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
When publishing information on donors-legal entities, to disclose data on the ultimate owners of companies, including closed joint stock companies
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
When publishing information on the finance sources of election funds, to disclose VAT Identification Number of the respective legal entity
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of campaign opportunities
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Access to Media
Recommendation:
To facilitate equal access to press, airtime and online media for all parties and candidates
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Media
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of campaign opportunities
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Balanced Coverage
Recommendation:
To respect principles of fairness and equality in regard to media coverage on parties and candidates running for elections
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Media
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Black PR
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Defamation
Recommendation:
To refrain from negative customised campaigning
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Media
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Recommendation:
To identify and punish the instigators and organizers of  such crimes as falsification of voting and election results committed by members of election commissions
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Recommendation:
To secure more scrupulous investigation of offenses and crimes, based on clear evidence  respecting the equality of testimony
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Use of state/administrative resources
Recommendation:
To persecute officials taking advantage of their discretion in the elections; to tighten control over campaigning activities carried out not at the expense of the election funds, though benefiting from administrative resources and taking advantage of unequal access to the media
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Freedom of campaign
Recommendation:
To prosecute perpetrators impeding legitimate campaigning activities carried out by candidates and electoral alliances
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Impartiality and independence
Recommendation:
To refrain from being guided by politically motivated orders
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Prohibited sources of funding
Recommendation:
The Russian Electoral Law should be amended by preventing contributions to the elections funds made by companies owned by foreign subjects or Russian Federation, Federal Subjects or municipalities of Russia
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
When publishing data on legal entities – donors, the information on company ultimate owners should be disclosed. The same applies to the closed joint-stock companies
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
When publishing information on the sources contributing to election funds, the VAT identification number of a legal entity should be diclosed. Otherwise, the identification of actual donor might be hindered by coincidence of companies under the same name
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Stability of legislation (eg. changes too close to elections)
Recommendation:
There is the necessity of providing stability of electoral legislation and its protection from manipulations for the benefit of ruling party or separate subjects of political process. Any changes of electoral legislation, first of all, should rely on ensuring principles of equality and the interests of voters.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Citizen Observation
Recommendation:
Necessary conditions for public observation of the elections have to be created. In particular, the institute of observation from public associations should be legislatively fixed.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Impartiality and independence
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
It is necessary to exclude participation of officials in organizing of election commissions. The size of a penalty for the administrative offenses connected with violation of electoral laws has to be increased. The persons who committed these offenses have to be deprived of the right to work in election commissions of any level within 5 years.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
Collecting signatures of municipal deputies and heads of municipalities on elections of heads of federal subjects of Russia has to be cancelled or quantitatively reduced to 1–3% for ensuring competitiveness of elections.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
Collecting voters signatures on elections of deputies of legislative and representative authorities and municipalities has to be cancelled or the electoral pledge should be restored.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Recommendation:
Heads of federal subjects and municipalities who are candidates on elections have to be obliged to take vacations for an election campaign period.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Recommendation:
It is necessary to strengthen sanctions and provide their inevitability for using the official position advantages on elections.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
State funding
Recommendation:
Any opportunity of using the public events organized at the expense of budget and (or) with participation of officials in the line of duty during a pre-election campaign should be completely eliminated.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Prohibited sources of funding
Recommendation:
It is necessary to modify the Russian electoral legislation filling a gap in the elections funds financing by the companies having foreign owners or belonging to the Russian Federation, federal subjects or municipalities.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Decision making
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Recommendation:
To guarantee fully independent, impartial, collegial, open and transparent decision-making process, as required by the current electoral law
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Impartiality and independence
Recommendation:
To refrain from being guided by the recommendations and unofficial orders that do not comply with the current electoral law
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Impartiality and independence
Recommendation:
To ensure greater protection of commission members refusing to commit fraudulent actions
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Decision making
Recommendation:
To preclude arbitrary and selective decision making
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of campaign opportunities
Recommendation:
To ensure the equality of all candidates and parties while nominating or registering their candidacies, collecting and verifying voters' signatures, as well as running the election campaign or other electoral activities
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of campaign opportunities
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Access to Media
Recommendation:
To facilitate the best possible environment for candidates' and parties' equal access to media
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Media
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Equality of campaign opportunities
Recommendation:
To develop a set of measures in order to detect and prevent covert campagning carried out under the guise of dissemination of information on the candidate's official duties
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Use of state/administrative resources
Recommendation:
To tighten control over the campaigning events carried out not only at the expense of election funds, though actually benefiting from administrative resources and unequal access to media
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
When publishing information on donors-legal entities, to disclose data on the ultimate owners of companies, including closed joint stock companies
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
When publishing information on the finance sources of election funds, to disclose VAT Identification Number of the respective legal entity
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of campaign opportunities
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Access to Media
Recommendation:
To facilitate equal access to press, airtime and online media for all parties and candidates
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Media
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of campaign opportunities
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Balanced Coverage
Recommendation:
To respect principles of fairness and equality in regard to media coverage on parties and candidates running for elections
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Media
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Black PR
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Defamation
Recommendation:
To refrain from negative customised campaigning
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Media
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Recommendation:
To identify and punish the instigators and organizers of  such crimes as falsification of voting and election results committed by members of election commissions
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Recommendation:
To secure more scrupulous investigation of offenses and crimes, based on clear evidence  respecting the equality of testimony
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Use of state/administrative resources
Recommendation:
To persecute officials taking advantage of their discretion in the elections; to tighten control over campaigning activities carried out not at the expense of the election funds, though benefiting from administrative resources and taking advantage of unequal access to the media
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Freedom of campaign
Recommendation:
To prosecute perpetrators impeding legitimate campaigning activities carried out by candidates and electoral alliances
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Impartiality and independence
Recommendation:
To refrain from being guided by politically motivated orders
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
It is necessary to coordinate standards of different laws in the direction of ensuring transparency of replenishment of candidates and parties' election funds. First of all, we advise to change the 10.2 item of Article 74 of Federal Law-20 and oblige candidates and parties to disclose information about all donors-legal entities, that donated more than 25 thousand rubles.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Recommendation:
All financial reports of regional offices and candidates for single-seat district at State Duma elections have to be published on the website of Central Election Commission according to the uniform standards, including obligatory publication of tax reference numbers of donor-legal entities. In the long term, we suggest to look into the possibility of obligatory publication of such financial reports in state automated system The Elections according to the uniform standards and concerning elections of all levels.
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Prohibited sources of funding
Recommendation:
It is necessary to introduce in the Russian legislation a concept of ultimate beneficial owners that will allow to put an end to the opportunities of financing of the Russian election campaigns by foreign persons and the companies with the state participation.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
All non-profit organizations giving financial support to parties or candidates have to be obliged to disclose information about their own donors, namely the name of the company or a name of the private person, tax reference number, the region and the sum of donation. Such reports have to be published on the website of the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Donations
Recommendation:
It is necessary to create mechanisms of stimulation of financial support of political party from their members and ordinary citizens. For instance, we suggest to make the amendments to the Tax Code allowing citizens to transfer no more than 1% of the paid personal income tax for support of concrete public organization, including political parties.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance oversight body
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Prohibited sources of funding
Recommendation:
What is still required it is improvement of work on identification of foreign and hidden (illegal) government financing of the political parties and also amendments to the Russian legislation that would put an end to legal possibilities of such funds transfers.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Donations
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Prohibited sources of funding
Recommendation:
It is necessary to start check of income of private persons if they donated to party funds more than 100,000 rubles within one year.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Parliamentary
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Use of state/administrative resources
Recommendation:
It is necessary to forbid giving public grants to the companies which owners are candidates for elective positions for public authorities and municipality and also to provide the mechanism of refunding if it was made before the start of candidate's election campaign.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Mandate
Recommendation:
the election commissions that organize the elections have no real instruments of control over "shadow" expenses. This situation can be remedied, if the functions of organizing elections and financial oversight are split between two different bodies. Such practice exists in other countries where the audit of candidates’ and parties’ financial reports is done either by government auditing agencies or by organizations established specifically for control over political finances. In some countries, such institutions may initiate large-scale compliance assessments that include both the review of documents and the public hearings
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
the rules of financial and legal reporting on candidates’ expenditures should be measurably simplified, with the focus shifting to disclosure of sources of funds donated to the electoral funds. This will both increase the financial transparency of election campaigns and help to take the salaries paid to the campaign staffers from “under the table.” The latter persons, we believe, are also interested in such development, because it will solve the problem of legitimizing their incomes. This is especially true since the candidates’ contracts with private persons are not subject to taxes
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Media
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Media Monitoring
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Regulatory Body and Oversight
Recommendation:
The Central Election Commission of Russia has to provide equality and fair position about candidates in the state media. The CEC needs to carry out its own monitoring of broadcasting programs during the election campaigns to find out unequal and prejudiced covering of a campaign and to take fast and effective measures against those who break the law. The movement "Golos" considers such monitoring has to be carried out, the methodology and results have to be disclosed for society and be regularly published. The ODIHR/OBSE have given similar recommendations for many years.
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Misuse of administrative resources
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Balanced Coverage
Recommendation:
The refusal of vacation for an election campaign of the current president or other officials running for the presidency distorts an information field and leads to violation of principle of equal rights of candidates. With a view to prevent it, the measures should be taken that would guarantee equal covering of candidates' activity in mass media at the legislative level.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Media
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Balanced Coverage
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Media Monitoring
Recommendation:
It is necessary to differentiate more clearly the concepts information and agitation in media. In particular, to give definition to the propaganda purpose and develop methodology of its identification. It is necessary for minimizing value judgements of disputable materials in media and for increasing legal definiteness. At the same time the principle of formation and activity of working groups on information disputes has to be changed: the groups have to make external independent expertizes and for this reason representatives of observers and journalistic public associations (the self-regulating organizations) and the academic community have to become a part of that groups.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Pluralism and competitiveness
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Balanced Coverage
Recommendation:
The format of so-called "debates" and other joint agitating events demands revision and, perhaps, legislative recognition to guarantee the right of voters to obtain objective and full information about program proposals of candidates and develop the real political debates. For example, the obligation to participate in a debate that is applied on other levels of elections is necessary to extend to candidates running for President of Russia.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Media
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Freedom of Expression
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Editorial Freedom
Recommendation:
The revealed system imbalance in freedom of speech in media demands serious legislative correction to return to the constitutional arrangements. At the same time, it is necessary to draw special attention to legislative regulation of instruments of state participation in media, including in financing. This have to guarantee and provide their real freedom and independence.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Donations
Recommendation:
The system of government financing of political parties has to be substantially revised in order to stimulate grassroots engagement and intensification of voter outreach. In order to do this, a possible solution may be to replace direct government financing of political parties and civil society institutions with an introduction of a selective tax that would allow citizens to independently direct a share of their taxes to support a specific party, NPO, or religious organization. In particular, the government may allow citizens to independently manage 0.5% of their personal income tax (this is approximately equal to the amounts that the state currently spends to support parties and NPOs), on the condition that it works out the mechanism for compensation of the lost tax incomes to the local and regional budgets, as well as the taxpayer’s ability to transfer the money to the specific regional branch of the organization. This will create competition not just for  votes, but for the voters’ money
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
Organizations that donate money to the funds of political parties and candidates should be obligated to disclose the information about the sources of their financing under the same conditions applicable to the parties and candidates themselves
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Prohibited sources of funding
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
It would be expedient to introduce to the Russian legislation the notion of the beneficiary (ultimate) owner, and to reconsider in connection with this the wording of the laws on the ban on foreign and government (other than established by law) financing of parties and candidates
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Prohibited sources of funding
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Use of state/administrative resources
Recommendation:
The government should introduce restrictions on provision of financial support to the parties and candidates by the legal entities that receive government procurement contracts and various forms of government support (grants, subsidies, etc.)
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Mandate
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Campaign finance oversight body
Recommendation:
The Golos Movement agrees with the opinion of OSCE ODIHR, which believes that “although the CEC cooperates with other state authorities in its effort to control the legality of the transactions made through electoral funds, it does not have the investigative capacity to check transactions potentially made outside the electoral funds. This effectively limits the accountability and transparency of the campaign finance.” We see the possible solution to the problem in the separation of functions of election organization and financial control, which could be done either through the establishment of a new body or through the transfer of financial monitoring functions to the existing entities, such as Russia’s Audit Chamber
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (disclosure, reporting)
Recommendation:
There should be a single generally accessible database of sponsors of candidates and political parties of all levels. All of the financial reports of the regional party branches and single mandate candidates should be published in machine-readable form in accordance with a common standard, and this should include the obligatory publication of the corporate donors’ TIN
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Donations
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Prohibited sources of funding
Recommendation:
It is necessary to review the incomes of private persons who have donated more than 100,000 rubles to the party funds within a single year
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
The procedure known as the municipal filter during the direct elections of the highest officials of subjects of the Russian Federation should be cancelled.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Citizen Observation
Recommendation:
The right of public associations to observers' referral to election commissions should be returned.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Use of computerized solutions / technologies in administration
Recommendation:
The legislation should warrant the obligatory selective recount of votes in the polling place equipped with an optical scan voting system.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Political Accountability Foundation Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Black PR
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Training
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Black PR
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Operational capacity (funding, staff, equipment)
Recommendation:
Increase in expenditure, both financial and organizational, allocated for training and education for members of precinct electoral commissions (OKW-1 and OKW-2)
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Presidential
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Technologies
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency and accountability
Recommendation:
The CEC of Russia shall store video recordings obtained during video surveillance at the elections of the President of the Russian Federation for at least one year from the date of the official publication of the election results. The CEC should extend the storage period for videos from polling stations, especially since this does not require additional financial costs, since they are already stored on the CEC's own servers
Action required:
Sub-legal change (eg. in regulations and instructions by election management body)
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
It is necessary to increase the amount of fines for administrative offenses related to violation of electoral legislation
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
It is necessary to transfer criminal offenses in the electoral sphere to the category of serious crimes
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Impartiality and independence
Recommendation:
Election commissions should not follow recommendations and informal instructions that do not comply with the current electoral legislation
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Impartiality and independence
Recommendation:
Provide protection for members of the commission in the event that they are held accountable for refusing to commit illegal actions
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad), Election Management Body, Ministry of Interior, Prosecutor's Office
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Recommendation:
Together with law enforcement agencies and experts, develop guidelines on the investigation of electoral crimes and the assessment of evidence
Action required:
Sub-legal change (eg. in regulations and instructions by election management body)
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior, Ministry of Justice, Prosecutor's Office
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Recommendation:
It is necessary to recheck all refusal materials on allegations of election fraud starting with the elections to the State Duma of Russia in 2016
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior, Prosecutor's Office
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Recommendation:
It is necessary to initiate criminal cases automatically if there is a video from the PEC with signs of election fraud
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior, Prosecutor's Office
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Recommendation:
There should be an explanation from the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation that in cases of falsification of elections it is inadmissible to terminate a criminal case due to the fact that it is impossible to assess compliance with the conditions for compensation for damage
Action required:
Sub-legal change (eg. in regulations and instructions by election management body)
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Media
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Balanced Coverage
Recommendation:
The media should objectively inform readers about the course of election campaigns, the development of the political system and provide a platform for different points of view
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Media, Media Regulatory and Oversight Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Media
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Freedom of Expression
Recommendation:
The media must resist coercion to participate in propaganda actions and manipulation of public opinion, publicly express solidarity with their colleagues who have faced pressure and censorship
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Media
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Media
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Impartiality and Independence
Recommendation:
When covering elections, the media should focus on the impact of political events and decisions on the status of voters' rights
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Media
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Media
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Access to Media
Recommendation:
The media should actively cover the electoral fraud trials, which usually take place during the inter-election period and remain non-public, which leads to impunity for those who violate the electoral rights of citizens
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Media
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Undue conduct, interference, obstruction, inaction
Recommendation:
Civil servants and law enforcement officials should not participate in the execution of unlawful instructions from their superiors aimed at restricting the electoral rights of citizens or abuse of "administrative resources" (including orders to organize falsifications or "cover up" falsifiers, provide support to specific candidates or obstruct their activities, pressure on citizens, etc.).
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ad Hoc Structures Created for Election Period, Authorities (general, broad), Election Management Body, Government, Local authorities, Ministry - other, Ministry of Interior, Ministry of Justice, Parliament, Prosecutor's Office
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Undue conduct, interference, obstruction, inaction
Recommendation:
Civil servants and law enforcement officials must protect their honest colleagues from undue pressure from their superiors
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ad Hoc Structures Created for Election Period, Authorities (general, broad), Election Management Body, Ministry of Interior, Ministry of Justice, Parliament, Prosecutor's Office
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Undue conduct, interference, obstruction, inaction
Recommendation:
Civil servants and law enforcement officers should make public the facts of administrative coercion and mobilization for campaigning events and on election day, including, send complaints to the relevant ministry and the prosecutor's office
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Authorities (general, broad), Election Management Body, Government, Local authorities, Ministry - other, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Ministry of Interior, Ministry of Justice, Parliament, Prosecutor's Office
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Undue conduct, interference, obstruction, inaction
Recommendation:
Civil servants and law enforcement officers should remember that their responsibilities are based on the protection of human and civil rights and freedoms
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ad Hoc Structures Created for Election Period, Authorities (general, broad), Election Management Body, Government, Local authorities, Ministry - other, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Ministry of Interior, Ministry of Justice, Parliament, Prosecutor's Office
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Voter rights
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of suffrage
Recommendation:
Organizations working with the most vulnerable groups should actively engage in efforts to prevent violations that could limit such groups in their suffrage. They should pay close attention to ensuring the rights of voters in places of military service, places of detention, medical institutions (freedom of expression, honesty of vote counting, etc.), demand an increase in the accessibility of the environment in election commissions, ensure fair representation, etc.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Non-governmental organizations and civil society
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral System
Recommendation:
NGOs should actively promote the ideas of electoral reform through their networks of contacts: tell about these problems to their voters, colleagues, relatives and friends, participate in the development of local regulations that promote the expansion and protection of electoral rights
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Non-governmental organizations and civil society
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Citizen Observation
Recommendation:
NGOs should involve citizens in observation, assist observer associations in sending observers to polling stations during elections
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Non-governmental organizations and civil society, Observer organizations
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Voter rights
Recommendation:
NGOs should encourage people to actively participate in elections and public events aimed at protecting electoral rights and fundamental freedoms. Help citizens to more actively defend their right to participate and be represented in elections
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Non-governmental organizations and civil society, Observer organizations
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Access of Observers
Subtopic of secondary thematic area:
Citizen Observation
Recommendation:
Observers and members of election commissions should participate in the observation and control of elections not only on election day, but throughout the entire election campaign
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Non-governmental organizations and civil society, Observer organizations
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Citizen Observation
Recommendation:
Observers and members of election commissions should assist in the implementation of the rights of candidates, as well as refuse to comply with or sabotage unlawful instructions from the authorities aimed at restricting the rights of voters
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Non-governmental organizations and civil society, Observer organizations
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Observation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Capacity and training
Recommendation:
Observers and members of election commissions should improve their own qualifications in matters of electoral legislation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Observer organizations
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Support signatures
Recommendation:
It is necessary to abandon the interpretation of signature collection procedures as some kind of “barriers” or “filters” to cut off supposedly “weak” candidates - only the expression of the will of voters on election day can show which of the candidates really turned out to be “strong” or “weak”. In order to refuse registration of candidates, only requirements that are fundamentally incompatible with the exercise of powers should remain. Everything else should be left to voters' responsibility
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body, Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Support signatures
Recommendation:
The voter should be provided with various options for the form to express support for candidates and party lists, for example: traditional - providing a signature to the candidate collector; proactive - when voters put their signatures in election commissions; electronic - using the website of the State Services and the websites of election commissions by filling out the appropriate electronic form; bank - transfer of a certain small amount of money through the banking system to a special account and even, under certain conditions, oral. The number of signatures collected in various ways and verified should be published and upon reaching the required number, the candidate should be automatically registered. The posting of the electoral deposit can also be seen as confirmation of the seriousness of the candidate's intentions.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body, Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Voter registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Centralized voter register
Recommendation:
In the conditions of increased mobility of citizens, it is necessary to abolish the "serfdom" of voters - voting only at the place of registration. The voter must, on his own initiative, determine the place for the exercise of active suffrage, depending on the place of his actual residence at the moment. The desire of the voter to influence the composition of the authorities in the place where he works and pays taxes is more important than his formal registration at his former place of residence
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body, Parliament
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
The attempt to "professionalize" the precinct election commissions did not make them either more professional or more honest. At the same time, the decisions of non-professional jurors in courts are more credible in society. The formation of election commissions can be carried out by analogy with the formation of the composition of the jury, by lot. In addition, any citizen should have the right to observe the voting and counting of votes.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral System
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Type of electoral system
Recommendation:
It is necessary to move towards the gradual introduction of more complex voting systems ("open lists", etc.), which, on the one hand, provide citizens with more rights and opportunities to influence the final composition of the elected authorities, and on the other hand, they put the voter in front of more difficult choice. The voter must consciously prepare to make his responsible choice, and not frivolously vote for the first candidate he comes across
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Media
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Editorial Freedom
Recommendation:
Consciousness of choice and responsibility for it are possible only with free access to all the necessary information. Substantive restrictions on campaigning, including the "day of silence", should be abolished. Respect for human and civil rights and freedoms, including freedom of assembly and expression, are necessary conditions for making an informed choice
Action required:
Legal change, Sub-legal change (eg. in regulations and instructions by election management body), Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body, Media, Parliament
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Election procedures (opening, voting, counting, tabulation)
Recommendation:
The procedure for counting votes adopted in the Russian elections does not guarantee its accuracy and honesty of the results obtained. Subjective interference of members of the commission and other persons can distort the expression of the will of voters anywhere and anytime. It is necessary that the counting of votes is carried out automatically, without the direct participation of members of the commissions. In addition, any citizen should have the right to observe the voting and counting of votes.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
Sharply toughen the responsibility for violations in the elections (especially for falsifications), transferring them to the category of serious crimes and increasing the amount of fines for administrative offenses. Responsibility for electoral crimes should not have a statute of limitations
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior, Parliament, Prosecutor's Office
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Donations
Recommendation:
Each citizen must decide for himself whether he wants to support one or another party financially and to what extent. This can be done both through the system of party contributions or voluntary donations, and by allowing citizens to dispose of 1% of the personal income tax paid by them, directing it to support parties or other public associations. The existing model of budgetary financing of parties has shown its inefficiency and viciousness and should be canceled
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Overall guarantees of transparency of the electoral process
Recommendation:
Citizens' voting on such an important issue as amendment of the Constitution should be preceded by the early adoption at the level of law of clear and stable rules for such voting. Such rules should not be established by decree and should not be situational and opportunistic. Their development is the responsibility of a representative body (Federal Assembly), which should create clear conditions for revealing the opinions of citizens and equal opportunities for all political actors (political parties and other public associations and initiative groups)
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Law-Making Process
Recommendation:
The only suitable form for revealing the will of citizens when adopting amendments to the Basic Law is a referendum. It is already obvious that the announced vote on amendments to the Constitution will not be a referendum in the sense of the federal constitutional law "On the Referendum of the Russian Federation." Golos believes that the refusal to use the legal mechanism of the referendum is an attempt to bypass the guarantees of the rights of citizens to participate in the referendum enshrined in the law, as well as the norms enshrined in the procedural codes that guarantee judicial protection of these rights and sanctions for their violation. We believe that such decisions - the conduct of a "vote-not-referendum" not envisaged by the legislation - lead to the destruction of the right. They show that any legal prohibition can be circumvented by devising a new quasi-legal mechanism.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Fundamental rights and freedoms
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Freedom of association
Recommendation:
Revealing the conscious will of the people is possible only as a result of a long and meaningful discussion, during which different points of view on the proposals made can be formulated and discussed. Citizens' rights to receive information and to campaign in these conditions should be at least not less than those provided for in the current legislation on elections and referenda. In particular, a full discussion of the issues put to the vote should be ensured, including the right to form campaign groups with their foundations. They should be given sufficient time to disseminate their opinion among the voters. The popular vote itself should only sum up a logical, legitimate and legal result of such a public discussion.
Action required:
Legal change, Sub-legal change (eg. in regulations and instructions by election management body), Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body, Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Legislation
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Implementation in line with the spirit of the law
Recommendation:
Voting should take place separately for each amendment, since not an integral document is put to the vote, as in the case of the adoption of the Constitution, but a large package of private amendments. One person may have opposite opinions on different amendments, and those who support one amendment may not support another. In this regard, we believe that the proposal to vote for the entire package of amendments at once will not allow revealing the position of citizens on specific issues. We consider "batch" voting to be a completely unacceptable technique.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of campaign opportunities
Recommendation:
The Golos movement demands the CEC of Russia to abandon campaigning on the approval of amendments to the Constitution of the Russian Federation and to ensure legal regulation of information and campaigning during the all-Russian vote, which provides equal rights to supporters and opponents of the adoption of amendments
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of campaign opportunities
Recommendation:
The Golos Movement requires the President, the Presidential Administration, other state authorities, regional authorities and local self-government bodies and their officials to refrain from illegal participation in campaigning during the nationwide vote, thereby refusing to use public (budget) resources to achieve a certain outcome voting, since otherwise would be a violation of the constitutional principle of free will and the principle of equality in relation to citizens who have different points of view on the issue put to the all-Russian vote.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ad Hoc Structures Created for Election Period, Authorities (general, broad), Election Management Body, Government, Local authorities, Ministry - other, Ministry of Interior, Parliament, Prosecutor's Office
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of campaign opportunities
Recommendation:
Federal legislation specifies that it is the responsibility of the Central Election Commission to protect the right of citizens to freely express their will. We believe that it would be reasonable to allocate part of the airtime for debates or clarification of the position of supporters and opponents of the amendments to the Constitution.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign regulation
Recommendation:
In order to take care of the health and life of citizens during the Covid epidemic, do not allow lotteries, drawing of prizes and other votes or polls to be held on voting days, which will contribute to the concentration and increase of contacts of citizens near the voting premises
Action required:
Sub-legal change (eg. in regulations and instructions by election management body), Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Equality of campaign opportunities
Recommendation:
The CEC of Russia, as the organizer of the vote, must refuse to conduct campaigning activities. Instead, it is necessary to make efforts to prevent the abuse of "administrative resources", to ensure neutral and objective information of citizens about the amendments, including equal representation of the positions of supporters and opponents of amendments to the Constitution, terminate agreements on information partnership with politically engaged structures, or, professing the principle of equality, conclude similar agreements with opponents of amendments
Action required:
Sub-legal change (eg. in regulations and instructions by election management body), Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign regulation
Recommendation:
Specialized public associations, in cooperation with companies that own social networks and other communication platforms, need to develop appropriate rules that would protect the sphere of mass communications from abuse, including when considering political issues
Action required:
Sub-legal change (eg. in regulations and instructions by election management body), Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ad Hoc Structures Created for Election Period, Authorities (general, broad), Media, Non-governmental organizations and civil society
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
To re-qualify electoral crimes - under parts 2 and 3 of Art. 141 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation "Obstruction of the exercise of electoral rights or the work of election commissions", according to Art. 142 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation "Falsification of electoral documents", Art. 142.1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation "Falsification of voting results", art. 142.2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation "Illegal issuance and receipt of a ballot paper" - in the category of serious crimes
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
Article 5.22 of the Code of Administrative Offenses of the Russian Federation (illegal receipt or issuance of a ballot paper) shall be excluded from the Code of Administrative Offenses of the Russian Federation, since there is a similar composition in the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. “Golos” believes that such violations of electoral legislation have a high degree of public danger and can only be criminal offenses.
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
Make changes to art. 142.2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, which provides for criminal liability for illegal issuance (receipt) of even one ballot paper as an offense with a high degree of public danger
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
Increase the fines provided for by Art. 5.6 of the Administrative Code of the Russian Federation (Violation of the rights of a member of the election commission, observers, representatives of the media, etc.) under Part 1 of Art. 5.6 of the Code of Administrative Offenses of the Russian Federation up to 10 thousand rubles, and under Part 2 of Art. 5.6 of the Administrative Code of the Russian Federation up to 30 thousand rubles. It is unacceptable to terminate such cases for insignificance, since actual impunity leads to a systematic violation of the rights of observers by members of the commissions
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
Sanctions Part 1 and Part 2. Art. 5.24 of the Code of Administrative Offenses of the Russian Federation are subject to revision towards an increase in administrative punishment up to 30 thousand rubles, since these offenses do not allow the observer to make sure that the ballots are counted correctly
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Electoral security
Recommendation:
Election commissions of various levels need jointly with law enforcement agencies and experts develop guidelines on the specifics of investigating electoral crimes, collecting and evaluating evidence
Action required:
Sub-legal change (eg. in regulations and instructions by election management body)
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body, Ministry of Interior, Ministry of Justice, Prosecutor's Office
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1567893600
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Recommendation:
It is necessary to initiate criminal cases automatically if there is a video from the PEC with signs of election fraud.
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior, Prosecutor's Office
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Repeated implementation:
1567893600
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Recommendation:
It is necessary to recheck all rejected materials on allegations of election fraud, starting with the elections to the State Duma of Russia (i.e. from 2016).
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior, Prosecutor's Office
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Referendum
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Access of observers
Recommendation:
Law enforcement agencies must refrain from following illegal instructions from members of commissions to remove observers and media representatives from the premises of polling stations
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Bribing and distribution of inducements to voters
Recommendation:
Commissions and law enforcement agencies should take effective measures in case of revealing the facts of coercion to early voting
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body, Ministry of Interior, Prosecutor's Office
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Early or Advance Voting
Recommendation:
Refuse from "exotic" forms of voting such as voting near the house, voting "at work" and from early voting "in settlements"
Action required:
Sub-legal change (eg. in regulations and instructions by election management body), Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Ballot box stuffing
Recommendation:
Precisely define the standards for safe bags and their sealing. It should also be provided that safe packages must be presented to observers, members of the commission before the start of voting on the main voting day. The numbers of the safe packages must be recorded in the act, and before opening them, they must be checked and announced. Observers should have the right to sign the act, and a copy of the act, immediately on the same day, should be given to everyone. The safe in which the safe packages are kept must also be sealed at night.
Action required:
Sub-legal change (eg. in regulations and instructions by election management body)
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Early or Advance Voting
Recommendation:
To carry out daily publication on the Internet of the number of voters who voted early, separately for each form of voting in the context of precinct commissions. This information should be posted on a daily basis in hard copy on the premises of PECs and TECs.
Action required:
Sub-legal change (eg. in regulations and instructions by election management body)
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Mobile Voting
Recommendation:
The voter list used for early voting outside the polling station must be bound and certified by the seal of the precinct commission. List binding is prohibited
Action required:
Sub-legal change (eg. in regulations and instructions by election management body)
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Early or Advance Voting
Recommendation:
Observers must be notified in advance of the early voting in any of the forms provided for by the Procedure. Information on early voting should be published on the website of the election commission of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation, as well as, if possible, on the websites of TECs and local administrations. Also, the PEC is to draw up and post a schedule of early voting outside the premises on Thursday, September 10, indicating the voting places. The time of transferring ballots from ballot boxes to safe-bags must be communicated in advance to all observers
Action required:
Sub-legal change (eg. in regulations and instructions by election management body)
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Sanctions
Recommendation:
Criminalize voters for receiving voting rewards
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Golos - open source data
Disclaimer:
Golos had to cancel its membership of the European Platform for Democratic Elections (EPDE) due to EPDE being listed as an "undesirable foreign organization" in Russia in March 2018. Due to this we exclusively evaluate open source information regarding election observation in Russia.
Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Early or Advance Voting
Recommendation:
Secure additional guarantees of public control over early voting
Action required:
Sub-legal change (eg. in regulations and instructions by election management body)
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Civil Network OPORA Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
Review the requirements for registration of candidates in the multi-mandate constituency in terms of compliance with the gender quota of 30%, make provision for imposing sanctions against those political which fail to comply with part 3 of article 4 of the Law of Ukraine “On Local Elections”, and legislate the comprehensive set of requirements for submission of documents by local organizations of political parties, which plan to register the list of candidates, in order to avoid ambiguous interpretations of these requirements at the level of TECs
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Civil Network OPORA Primary Thematic Area: Electoral System
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Districts and constituencies
Recommendation:
Determine the maximum permissible percentage of deviation from average number of voters in territorial election constituencies in order to ensure the equal weight of each mandate at the stage of their division into constituencies
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Civil Network OPORA Primary Thematic Area: Campaign
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign regulation
Recommendation:
Establish administrative liability of potential participants in the electoral process who began their activities with signs of campaigning after the official start of the election campaign, but prior to their actual registration as electioneerers, in order to ensure equal opportunities for candidates
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Civil Network OPORA Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Composition and appointment
Recommendation:
Analyze the results of creation of territorial election constituencies, and make public the conclusions with the internationally recognized standards for territorial organization of elections at the level of TECs, and forecasts on adherence to the principle weight of each Make recommendations for settling the issue through law on the grounds of these conclusions
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Civil Network OPORA Primary Thematic Area: Candidate and party registration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Registration requirements
Recommendation:
Promote the uniform application of the law of Ukraine throughout Ukraine, especially at the stage of registration of candidates
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Civil Network OPORA Primary Thematic Area: Party functioning and internal party democracy
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Capacity (nomination of commission members, proxies, observers, etc.)
Recommendation:
To ensure effective work of local party cells and candidate representatives as part of electoral commissions, especially at precinct commission level, considering that those are formed at their minimal composition
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Political parties
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Civil Network OPORA Primary Thematic Area: Complaints and appeals
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Due process
Recommendation:
To actively use opportunities of legal contestation of decisions and actions of electoral commissions as well as violations of election legislation without excessive applications to Central Election Commission
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Political parties, Political Parties and Campaign Oversight Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Civil Network OPORA Primary Thematic Area: Electoral System
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Districts and constituencies
Recommendation:
To ensure implementation of comprehensive electoral reform based on the principle of inclusiveness, including revision of current legislation on local elections (in particular, revision of procedure for formation of electoral districts)
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Civil Network OPORA Primary Thematic Area: Election day
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Election procedures (opening, voting, counting, tabulation)
Recommendation:
To ensure effective control over application of legislation by members of election commissions at the stage of vote tabulation
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Civil Network OPORA Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Training
Recommendation:
On the eve of Election Day in the first local elections scheduled for December 18, 2016, to provide election commissions with further clarification on inadmissibility of issuance of ballot papers to voters without presentation of valid ID documents, while ensuring that TECs and PECs are adequately informed in this regard
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Low
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Obsolete
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Civil Network OPORA Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Voter education and information
Recommendation:
Together with territorial election commissions, to ensure appropriate informing of voters about what is special about the first local election, about their rights and responsibilities, as well as about responsibility for violating the election legislation
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Obsolete
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Civil Network OPORA Primary Thematic Area: Electoral System
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Districts and constituencies
Recommendation:
Reform of the local election legislation has to include a systemic revision of approaches to forming electoral districts so as to make the principle of equal weight of votes possible to implement in practice
Action required:
Legal change
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Parliament
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Civil Network OPORA Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Recommendation:
To undertake appropriate preventive measures and immediately respond to abuses of power and obvious violations of the election legislation at the stage of campaigning as well as during vote count and obtaining election results
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior
Implementation Status:
Partially implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Civil Network OPORA Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Electoral security
Recommendation:
To raise awareness of all participants of the election process about consequences of and responsibility for election legislation violations
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Civil Network OPORA Primary Thematic Area: Electoral security and law enforcement
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Investigation and prosecution
Recommendation:
To ensure prompt investigation into violations committed in the first local elections held on December 11, 2016, while informing the media and the public about investigation findings
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Ministry of Interior, Ministry of Justice, Prosecutor's Office
Implementation Status:
Obsolete
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Civil Network OPORA Primary Thematic Area: Campaign financing
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Campaign finance regulations
Recommendation:
The CEC and election commissions of all levels should conduct awareness-raising campaign and tighten control over the process of financial reporting by electoral subjects
Action required:
Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
Medium
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Not implemented
Election Type:
Local / Regional / Municipal
Recommending Organization: Civil Network OPORA Primary Thematic Area: Election administration
Subtopic of primary thematic area:
Transparency (publication of information, decisions, agenda, etc.)
Recommendation:
To ensure effective control over the application of legislation by members of election commissions at the stage of certification of election results
Action required:
Sub-legal change (eg. in regulations and instructions by election management body), Practice / Implementation
Degree of Recommendation's Priority / Urgency / Relevance:
High
Body / Institution Responsible for Implementation:
Election Management Body
Implementation Status:
Rejected